# A row of lemurs, one off-key: how the ear-training app Sine turned a mini-game into 30M views on TikTok

> Source: https://stringers.io/en/apps/ios_6809608874.html (Stringers / 什么值得做, generated 2026-11-20)
> Stringers tracks which small products suddenly took off each day, investigates why one by one, and distils playbooks from them. Numbers come from 15 databases we collect daily, each with source and date.
> For agents: these investigations and the underlying databases (verified revenue, App Store / Google Play charts, ad libraries, GitHub, Product Hunt…) are queryable live over MCP — tools feed (daily breakouts) / plays (playbooks) / hot / products / data. Setup: https://github.com/komako-workshop/stringers (the user signs in with Google at stringers.io/en/start.html to get a personal URL). Site index: https://stringers.io/llms.txt

> The "who's off-key" game inside the app cuts into a 15-second guessing video. Swap the instrument or the setting and you have a new episode. After Oct 6 switched to this format, the median views per video went from 8,600 to 297k. A character storyline built a fanbase on top of that, and cheap pricing, no ads, and a new version every few days kept the traffic.

[Mobile App](https://stringers.io/en/apps/index.md) · iOS · written 11-7

Sine: Ear Training Games · Ethan Liao

# A row of lemurs, one off-key: how the ear-training app Sine turned a mini-game into 30M views on TikTok

**What it is:** A phone app with a lemur mascot teaching ear training and music theory. It has short lessons and mini-games like "who's off-key in the band," no ads, and costs $14.99 a year.

**Why it took off:** The app's "who's off-key" game cuts into a 15-second guessing video; swap the instrument or setting and you have a new episode. After Oct 6 switched to this format, the median views per video rose from 8,600 to 297k. Add character storylines that built a fandom, plus a low price, no ads, and an update every few days to catch the traffic.

**B** **How to ride it** Don't copy it as-is into English-speaking markets. Copy the method: build a small game where changing one variable gives you a new episode, and make the short video and the app the same thing. Move it to a language (Japanese, Korean, Chinese) or a skill (singing off-key, rhythm, foreign-language pronunciation) it hasn't reached yet.

Grade B: the method is clear, it gets users without paid ads, and the copycat accounts haven't taken off yet, so there's room to switch language or skill. But its revenue is completely invisible, its users are mostly teens who don't like to pay, the English-language format is already held by it and the fandom, and views are falling. Whispered in small circles

Est. monthly revenue (App Store) **at least $10K** We estimated this from its chart ranks and rating growth across storefronts, calibrated against verified revenue; typical error is 2–3x. Apps earning $10K+/month are often underestimated, hence "at least". Read it as a tier, not an exact number.

Data (updated daily) · launched 2026-09-18 · US store rating 947 · charted in 11-20 of 11 stores

iOS · best category chart rank · by store

US store Korea Japan

Data 2026-10-28 → 2026-11-20 (24 days, 21 observations). Lower rank is higher; gaps mean it wasn't charted that day

iOS · rating count · US store

Data 2026-10-28 → 2026-11-18 (22 days, 19 observations). Apple doesn't publish download counts; rating growth is a proxy for downloads.

A ear-training app that only launched in September, with lessons about the same as an old-school app from ten years ago, got around 31M views and 28k Android installs in one month off its own TikTok, with no ad spend that anyone can see. The secret isn't the ear training. It has a mini-game, and cut as-is it is a 15-second guessing video. Below: what the format is, why it keeps working, where the money is, who's copying it, and what you can borrow.

### a long-trombone video

On Oct 2026 6, TikTok account @learn.sine posted a video: a row of lemurs that all look identical, each holding a trombone, taking turns playing the same note, one of them slightly out of tune. The caption read: "One of these trombones is out of tune. Can you hear which one? Round 2 is just a hair off. Comment A, B or C before the answer."

This one hit 170k views. Before it, the account had posted 23 videos with a median of 8,600 views.

Three days later, on Oct 9, the same setup came back with an oboe, titled "OBOE EDITION!", and the caption thanked the fans who had asked for oboe in the comments. That one reached 8M views and 114k likes by Nov 2.33. Since Oct 6 the account has posted 83 videos, with a median of 297k views and 74 over 100k (TikTok profile data, 11-08).

### What it is

Sine: Ear Training Games launched on iOS in Sep 18 and on Android in Oct 4. The lead character is a lemur called Sine. The content is ear training and music theory: intervals, chords, rhythm, sight-singing, absolute pitch, with short lessons and a choice of your own instrument sound (including transposing instruments). Beyond the lessons there are a few mini-games, one called Out of Tune, which is the "which one is off" from the video.

The App Store developer is listed as an individual, "Ethan Liao", who has only this one app. Google Play and the website terms say MAOI LLC. The About page on the site says "a handful of people… across a few time zones", and the art, recording, lessons, code, translations into 11 languages, and customer support are all done in-house. The founder replies in App Store reviews, calling themselves "founder of sine here". There is one lead that probably matches: a high-school jazz pianist in San Francisco, 2025 years old in 15, also named Ethan Liao, gave a school TEDx talk on Oct 26 titled "Music Is Built, Not Born", which is nearly the same idea as the first line of Sine's early store copy, "Perfect pitch isn't innate, it's a skill." Many people share that name, so this is only a strong lead, unverified.

It didn't start out as an ear-training game either. The early title was "Sine: Learn Perfect Pitch", focused on absolute pitch. Out of Tune was added in an early-October 0.7.0 build, and the release notes say "Out of Tune leads the Games tab", the same week the TikTok format switched.

### Why this format, specifically

Ear-training apps have been around for a while. Perfect Ear has 8.73M installs on Google Play. Sine took off by doing three things the old apps didn't.

**The gameplay is the content.** Out of Tune is vertical by nature, with a row of characters, and you can answer after one listen. Cut as-is, it's already a guessing puzzle. Viewers play it in the video, and after downloading they can keep playing in the app. In the same niche, Trill has creators say "this app is called Trill" on camera, getting a few hundred to ten thousand views per post, and Pitch Trainer buys ads on Meta. Their videos sell the product. Sine's videos are the product.

**It can reskin endlessly.** The structure stays the same, and swapping the instrument or the setting makes a new episode: a saxophone on the subway, a bass clarinet in an autumn park, a trombone in a cathedral, a tuba at a Bavarian beer festival, a violin in a dragon's lair. It posts 2 to 5 videos a day, every caption asks "which instrument next", the instruments named in comments get made the next day, and the captions give explicit thanks ("huge shoutout to @chrissstopjer for the idea"). Viewers comment "3/3" with their score, and reporting a score pushes the engagement up by itself.

**The audience is well targeted.** The tags are fixed as #bandkids #marchingband #eartraining, aimed at American middle- and high-school band and orchestra students. Those kids are already on TikTok all day, and "someone in your section is always out of tune" is already a running joke with them. One video's caption read "Sorry for all the trumpet hate recently", with 330k views.

### From puzzle account to series

Starting Oct 22, it gave the lemurs a storyline: the off-key one, named C, gets kicked out of the band and locked in a dungeon, escapes with another named Nocturne, the queen chases them, and the clown Bobo pops up now and then. The puzzle is still "which one is off", but viewers now have a reason to come back. On Oct 28 a caption joked: "This was supposed to be educational content, and now you're all just here for the plot."

The storyline brought in a fandom. Under #learnsine on TikTok there are fan edits and fan art. One "justice for C chat" video got 210k views, one "#DRUMMERC" got 190k views, and there are dedicated fan accounts for C. Starting Nov 1 it began posting "dev logs" explaining why the paywall was changed, bringing feedback from comments, email, and DMs into public view.

The copycat accounts that followed could copy the format, but not this layer.

### How views turned into downloads

- **Android** : Google Play installs 16,410(10-29) → 28,381(11-08), with 1,000–1,300,555 new ratings a day at an average of 4.84 stars.

- **iOS** : global ratings 550(10-28) → 898(11-08); US store 766 ratings at 4.89 stars (11-07). Using the Android ratings-to-installs ratio of about 2%, rough iOS downloads are in the range of 4–50k.

- **Charts** : In the US it only made the Education Top Free chart, somewhere between #130 and #200. 11-08 is now on the Education charts in 36 countries (only 8 at end of October), with its best ranks in small markets like Barbados (#44) and Singapore (#51). Searching "ear training" in the US App Store, it ranks #2 (11-07), and store search is starting to send it traffic.

- **Other platforms** : the same videos also go to Instagram Reels (@eartraining.games, about 96k followers, scrape date unverified) and YouTube Shorts (18.6k subscribers).

One US review reads: "I came from all the advertisements on TikTok". But none of its TikTok posts is labeled as an ad, and it doesn't show up in the Meta ad library. The most likely explanation is that users took organic videos for ads. Whether it paid to boost organic posts can't be seen from outside. No media coverage, and almost nobody mentions it on X.

### Money: strangely cheap

The free tier includes all the intro lessons, every instrument, and friend groups, and the game can be played several times every 6 hours. The membership is called Encore: a 7-day trial, then $14.99 a year, or $1.99 a month, or $29.99 one-time. The family plan covers up to 6 people for $24.99 a year. No ads, and no ad or tracking SDKs were found. The common approach for new apps like this is a survey followed by a hard $7.99-a-week paywall, with comparable annual plans around $40–80.

The US reviews praise exactly these points: "I love the cheaper price point", "The app does not ask you to pay for a subscription and does not have ads", "the mascot is adorable". Nearly all the complaints are about the paywall. One user who has played piano for three years said the most important feature was "locked behind their subscription wall". The founder replied personally: "i 100% hear you". These features were only proofs of concept, the interval and chord modes would be rebuilt and made free, and intro theory, rhythm, and notation would be added. In later versions the intro lessons did move into the free tier. It went from 0.6.0 to 0.20.0 in just October, shipping a version roughly every 2–3 days.

The rating score 4.9 is designed too: the prompt only pops up when users come back the next day, right after they've finished something worth celebrating.

The cost is that the revenue is invisible. It has never charted in any country's overall Top Grossing, only appearing near the bottom of Education Top Grossing in a few countries like Norway, Hong Kong, Indonesia, and Portugal, and not at all in the US Education Top Grossing. Third-party estimates put monthly revenue under $10k (estimate, unreliable). The people coming in from the videos are mostly teens, who like to play but don't necessarily pay.

### Who's competing, and who's copying

| Product | Scale | How it differs from Sine |
|---|---|---|
| Perfect Ear | Google Play 8.73M installs | Established all-in-one tool, one-time purchase, no characters, no short videos |
| Pitch Trainer | Google Play 217k installs, +15k in 7 days; Meta running 264 ads | Survey plus a hard $7.99/week paywall, relying entirely on paid acquisition; installs are 8× Sine's, with poor reviews |
| Trill | 1,921 iOS ratings, best rank 121 on the US Education Top Grossing chart | Creators read the script on camera, getting a few hundred to ten thousand views per post, with no character of its own |
| Earpeggio, Tone, etc. | A few thousand to ten thousand iOS ratings each | Single-function tool, no gamification |
| Duolingo Music | Inside the Duolingo main app | Teaches notation and simple melodies, shallow on ear training |

The copycats have already arrived. Pitch Master (about 5,700 followers) started posting at the end of October: "PIANO EDITION — Find the Imposter. Four moles. One is out of tune. Three rounds", with moles and birds replacing the lemurs, getting 500 to 27k views per post. @absolutepitchtrainer (394 followers) started posting in Nov 4: "One is out of tune… Comment how many you got out of 3", getting a few hundred views per post. As of Nov 8, none of the copycats has taken off, two orders of magnitude behind Sine.

### How long can it stay hot

On a weekly basis, its TikTok views were 9.07M (week of 10-05), 6.15M, 8.69M, 3.89M, and 3.19M (week of 11-02, with the latest posts still gaining traction). The median per post fell from about 300k in mid-October to about 240k in November. The same format has run for over a month, and viewers are getting tired of it.

It's looking for its next season: in early Nov 5 it teased a new rhythm game, "WHO'S OFF TEMPO?", with 480k views. The Nov 6 0.22.0 build added the rhythm game Round the Fire, new lessons, and a metronome, and later "who's dragging the beat" posts got 20–400k. Oddly, views are declining while the iOS rating growth picked up in 11-07 and 11-08, and the number of charting countries rose from about ten to 36. It could be the new version, or store search rankings rising. Unverified.

### If it were you

**B** Don't copy Sine, copy its method. The English-language, US band-student niche is already taken by it, and copycat accounts are two orders of magnitude behind on views. What's worth doing is taking the "the gameplay is the video" idea to a language or audience it hasn't reached. The cost: the money is invisible from outside, teen payment is weak, and this step is a bet you have to make yourself.

**Who it suits** 1–3 people, with someone who can make animated characters and someone who can record instruments, and people willing to post 2–5 short videos a day and personally reply to comments. Ideally you're already in an instrument community (played wind instruments, been in an orchestra), so you know the inside jokes. Being able to make a small game matters more than being able to write lessons.

**Who it doesn't suit** Anyone who wants to copy the "find the off-key one" format as-is in English (Pitch Master has already shown that doesn't work); people who only write code and won't make content every day; anyone counting on paid acquisition to get going (the cost of this approach is in content, not ads).

**How to do it** Three paths, from most to least certain:

1. **Switch language and audience.** Japanese, Korean and Chinese school band kids are just as big, but the art style and memes need a full redo, not a translation. On the Chinese side, piano and instrument students already take ear-training exams as part of their grades, and parents are the ones paying, so this may convert better than with US teens (inference).

2. **Keep the structure, change the skill.** "One in the lineup is off, can you spot it?" works for more than pitch: who sang flat (singers outnumber instrumentalists by a lot), who dragged the beat (Sine is already heading there), which sound is wrong in a foreign language. Pick a niche that's already active on short video first.

3. **Do what Sine doesn't.** Sine's advanced content (chords, harmony, sight-singing) is still in progress, and serious users find it shallow. Build a deeper version for people prepping for grading or band auditions, but keep distribution on playable short videos.

Whichever route you pick, the core is the same: build a mini-game where the scene stays fixed and changing one variable makes a new episode, so the video and the app are the same thing. Price like Sine: low annual fee, a generous free tier, no ads, and put the rating prompt right after the user has just had fun.

**How to get users.** Run your own TikTok, Douyin and Xiaohongshu accounts, and post the same video to Reels and Shorts. For the first two weeks, test 3–5 formats a day. Lock in whichever one breaks 100k on a single video and post it daily. Ask "what do you want to hear next?" in every caption, make the next video from whatever people name, and thank them by name. Once you have a steady audience, add a character storyline. Tag only one niche.

**Deadline.** Post 30 test videos by the end of January of year 2027. If none of the first 30 break 100k, switch formats or audience instead of pushing on. For a Japanese school band angle, new students join in April, so have a working account before March.

**Signs you've misread it.** (1) Pitch Master or another copycat gets 500k+ on a single video. That means the format isn't tied to the character, competition arrives faster than you think, and the window is closing. (2) Sine's weekly views drop below 1M and the rhythm game doesn't pick things up. That means this kind of format fatigues in a month or so, and you need to keep rotating formats. (3) By February of year 2027, Sine still isn't in the top 100 of any country's Education Top Grossing chart. That means the traffic isn't turning into money, so the method may be copyable but the business may not be. (4) The reverse: it charts in the US Education Top Grossing, or discloses revenue. Then the model makes money, so start the translation work now.

[iOS store page ↗](https://apps.apple.com/app/id6809608874)

**Research notes: competitor table, acquisition evidence, full research report**

Competitors

| Name | Where | Launched | Scale | How it differs from this one |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Perfect Ear(Crazy Ootka) | Android | 2013(iOS 2019) | 8.73M installs on Play, +7 in 7,012 days; iOS rating 1,936 | Long-running full-featured tool, one-time purchase, no characters or short videos |
| Pitch Trainer | Android | iOS 2026-01, Play 2026-06 | 217k installs on Play, +7 in 15,356 days; Meta running 264 ads | Survey plus a hard $7.99/week paywall, all growth from Meta ads; Sine is organic short video plus $14.99/year |
| Trill: Ear Training Daily | iOS | 2025-08 | iOS rating 1,921, +7 in 58 days; best rank on the US Education Top Grossing chart is #121 | TikTok runs on paid UGC creators reading scripts, a few hundred to 10k views per video; no owned IP, and no game mechanic that cuts straight into a video |
| Pitch Master(Namu) | iOS | 2026-06 | iOS 667 ratings, 7 days +76 | Copies Sine's find-the-off-key format but has no fanbase and no serialized story, so views are two orders of magnitude lower |
| Earpeggio / Functional Ear Trainer / Tone | iOS | 2014 / 2016 / 2016 | iOS 9,775 / 3,849 / 10,385 ratings | Single-function ear training tool, no gamification, characters or social features |
| Complete Ear Trainer | Android | 2014 | Play 1.04M installs | Serious level-based training aimed at people who study seriously |
| EarMaster / Tenuto / SoundGym | iOS | 2011–2016 | hundreds to thousands of ratings | Courses and tools for people who study theory and audio in depth, priced higher |
| Duolingo Music | Big-company features | 2023 | Inside the Duolingo main app | Teaches note reading and simple melodies, shallow on listening; Sine focuses on hearing |
| tonedear.com / musictheory.net / teoria | Web | Years | Free web tool | Free and full-featured, but no games, progression or characters |

Where users come from

- **Verified.** **Sine's own TikTok @learn.sine (find-the-off-key quiz format)** : median views of the first 23 videos before 10-06 were 8,600; after 10-06, the median of the next 83 videos was 297k, with the top one, "OBOE EDITION!", at 10-09 2.33M views. Hashtags #bandkids #marchingband. Instruments requested in comments were made as the next video (TikHub).

- **Verified.** **Character storyline serials and fan edits** : from 10-22, the storyline added C being locked in a dungeon and escaping with Nocturne. Fan edits under #learnsine hit 210k (@toast3xoticbutterz) and 190k (@sleepysan_) views, there are dedicated fan accounts, and people discuss the art style on Reddit r/isitAI.

- **Verified.** **Instagram Reels and YouTube Shorts posted in sync** : Instagram @eartraining.games has 96.1K followers and 117 posts; YouTube @learnsine has 18.6K subscribers and 53 Shorts. Commenters say they found it via Insta and Shorts.

- **Verified.** **App Store search** : searching "ear training" in the US store ranks #2 (iTunes Search API, 11-07), rating 4.9. The rating prompt is timed for when users are happy.

- **Verified.** **Android launch caught the spike** : 10-04 went to Android; two days later the format took off. Play reached ~28k installs within about a month.

- Inference. **Paid ads** : a comment says "came from all the advertisements on TikTok," but none of the TikTok posts are labeled as ads, and neither the Meta Ad Library nor the TikTok EU ad library shows any. Whether they boosted posts with Spark Ads can't be seen.

- Inference. **In-product acquisition (friend circles, family plan, classroom plan)** : Sine Circles launched 10-12, Encore Family has an invite link, and the website is collecting classroom plan requests from music teachers. Effect unclear.

## Why Sine: Ear Training Games (iOS 6809608874) took off

**Bottom line** : Sine's course content is about the same as long-running ear training apps from a decade ago (interval recognition, chords, absolute pitch). It took off because of one mini-game, "Out of Tune" (find the wrong instrument in a band), **which cuts straight into a 15-second TikTok quiz** . In Oct 6 the own account switched to this format, and single-video views went from thousands to hundreds of thousands, sometimes over a million. The mascot lemur C and Nocturne's serialized plot then built a fanbase. Nearly all users come from its own short videos (mostly TikTok, with the same clips on Instagram Reels and YouTube Shorts), and no paid ads show up in the ad libraries. Users stay because there are no ads, the free tier is generous, the annual plan is only $14.99 (comparable apps cost about $40–80), and a new version ships every 2–3 days, with the instruments and games requested in comments built into both the videos and the app. The differentiation isn't ear training itself. It's that **the game is the content** and **the character IP** . That is why it worked.

### 1. Basic facts

- The iOS developer account is the individual "Ethan Liao" (developer id 6809608877, with only this one app under it). On Google Play the publisher is MAOI LLC, and the website terms say "Sine is made by MAOI LLC" ([learnsine.com/terms](https://learnsine.com/terms)). The About page says the team is "a handful of people… across a few time zones," and the art, recording, courses, code, translations into 11 languages and support are all done in-house ([learnsine.com/about](https://learnsine.com/about)).

- The founder's identity is **unverified** . On the App Store, replies to reviews are signed "founder of sine here." There is one likely lead: Ethan Liao, a jazz pianist and composer from University High School in San Francisco, 2025 years old in 15, who played Carnegie Hall and won a composition award from Jazz at Lincoln Center ([SFist 2025-04-18](https://sfist.com/2025/04/18/sf-high-school-freshman-to-be-honored-at-the-lincoln-center-after-winning-prestigious-national-competition/)). In 2026-10-26 he gave a talk at TEDxSFUHS Youth titled "Music Is Built, Not Born" ([YouTube](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnDTX94hj40)). That title closely matches the opening line of Sine's early store copy, "Most people are told perfect pitch is you are born with. It is not. It is a skill" ([chartoo archived 0.10.1 description](https://hk.chartoo.com/itunes/app/6809608874-sine-ear-training-games)). But many people are named Ethan Liao (LinkedIn also turns up a Duke student and a software engineer), so this is only a strong lead.

- Timeline: iOS launched 2026-09-18; Android followed 10-04 (TikTok: "We are now on ANDROID!!"); as of 11-06 the version number had reached 0.22.0. The website release log shows the version going from 0.6.0 to 0.20.0 in October alone, **roughly one release every 2–3 days** ([learnsine.com/releases](https://learnsine.com/releases)). The key Out of Tune game was added 0.7.0 (early October), with the release note "Out of Tune leads the Games tab," the same week Sine switched formats on TikTok (10-06).

- The positioning changed: early titles and the website said "Learn perfect pitch," focused on absolute pitch. It's now "Ear Training Games," a full course in theory, rhythm, sight-singing and harmony plus mini-games ([learnsine.com](https://learnsine.com/), Play description).

- Pricing (from the website): the free tier includes all the beginner courses, every instrument and the friend circles, and lets you play the game a few times every 6 hours. Encore subscription has a 7-day trial, then $14.99/year, or $1.99/month, or a one-time $29.99 purchase. Encore Family covers up to 6 people for $24.99/year. No ads, and a third-party SDK scan found no ad or tracking SDKs ([AppGoblin](https://appgoblin.info/apps/6809608874)).

- The rating prompt is designed: it shows up after the user comes back the next day and has done something worth celebrating, then asks for a rating in one tap (0.6.0 release notes). That helps explain the 4.9 rating.

### II. Growth data

- **iOS (appstore library)** : combined rating across all stores 550 (10-28) → 898 (11-08), +348 in 11 days; US store 512 → 759, +131 in the last 7 days. The iTunes lookup shows 766 US ratings at 4.89 (11-07).

- Charts: the US only charted on the Education Top Free list, bouncing between #136 and #201 (10-28 #136,11-08, #144). The recall card's "US Education Top Free #41" doesn't match our library, and App Store web snapshots in each language show #131–#198, so it's **unverified** . 11-08 It also charted in 36 countries' Education charts (10-28 of them in 8). The best ranks are in small countries: Barbados 44, Cyprus 46, Macau 47, Singapore and Slovenia 51.

- Grossing charts: it never made the overall grossing chart. It only appeared near the bottom of Education Top Grossing in Norway (109), Hong Kong (120), Indonesia (130), Portugal (149), Denmark (157) and Uruguay (164) (appstore library, chart_rank). It never charted on the US Education Top Grossing. AppGoblin estimates monthly revenue at under $10K (third-party estimate, not reliable).

- **Android (googleplay library)** : installs 16,410 (10-29) → 28,381 (11-08), +7 in the last 8,445 days, averaging 1,000–1,300 a day; 555 ratings at 4.84. Going by the ratio of ratings to installs (about 2%), iOS downloads might be in the 4–50k range (**estimate** ).

- **TikTok @learn.sine (TikHub, pulled 11-08)** : 61,430 followers, 106 videos, 31.6M total views, 1.66M likes, 26k comments, 80k shares. None are labeled as ads.
    - The first 10-06 videos before 23: 620k total views, median 8,600, and only 1 broke 100k.
    - The 10-06 videos from 83 on: 31M total views, median 297k, and 74 broke 100k. The top one is "OBOE EDITION!" from 10-09 with 2.33M views and 114k likes; next is "VIOLIN AUDITION" at 10-20 1.13M, trumpet at 10-21 910k, tuba at 10-09 900k.
    - Weekly plays: week 41 (10-05 to 10-11) 9.07M, week 42 6.15M, week 43 8.69M, week 44 3.89M, week 45 (11-02 to 11-08) 3.19M. **Clearly cooling off** : median per video dropped from about 300k in October to about 240k in November. 11-05's upcoming rhythm game "WHO'S OFF TEMPO" pulled 480k, which is them looking for the next season of this format.

- Other platforms: Instagram @eartraining.games has 96.1K followers and 117 posts (search snapshot, date unverified), more than its TikTok following; YouTube @learnsine has 18.6K subscribers and 53 Shorts (11-08 page). Their site says "5,000,000+ answers from Sine players".

### III. Competitors

| Product | Where | Launched | Scale | How it differs from Sine |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Perfect Ear(Crazy Ootka) | Android/iOS | 2013(Play)/2019(iOS) | 8.73M installs on Play, +7 in 7,012 days; iOS rating 1,936 | Long-running all-in-one tool, one-time purchase, no characters, no short videos |
| Complete Ear Trainer | Android/iOS | 2014 | Play 1.04M installs; iOS 203 ratings | Serious level-based training aimed at people who study seriously |
| Earpeggio / Functional Ear Trainer / Tone | iOS | 2014 / 2016 / 2016 | iOS 9,775 / 3,849 / 10,385 ratings | Single-function tools (intervals, in-key tones, absolute pitch), no gamification or IP |
| Pitch Trainer(Ear & Pitch Training Studios) | iOS/Android | iOS 2026-01, Play 2026-06 | 217k installs on Play, 7 days +15,356; iOS rating 528; Meta running 264 ads, 820 historically | Follows the fitness/language app playbook: quiz onboarding plus a hard paywall ($7.99/week), relying entirely on Meta paid acquisition. Installs are 8x Sine's, but reviews are worse; Sine runs on organic traffic and a cheap subscription |
| Trill: Ear Training Daily | iOS | 2025-08 | iOS rating 1,921, +7 in 58 days; best rank on the US Education Top Grossing chart is #121 | Also on TikTok, but it hires UGC creators to say "this app is called Trill" on camera, getting a few hundred to ten thousand plays per video; no IP of its own |
| Pitch Master(Namu) | iOS | 2026-06 | iOS 667 ratings, 7 days +76 | From late October it copied Sine's "find the out-of-tune / three rounds" format with moles and birds, but plays are two orders of magnitude lower |
| EarMaster / Tenuto / SoundGym | iOS/web | 2011–2016 | hundreds to thousands of ratings | Courses and tools for people seriously studying theory and audio, expensive |
| Duolingo Music | Big-company features | 2023 | Inside the Duolingo main app | Teaches note reading and simple melodies, shallow ear training; Sine focuses exclusively on listening |
| tonedear.com, musictheory.net, teoria | Web | Years | Free web tool | Free and feature-rich, but no games, progression, or social |

Searching "ear training" on the US App Store, Sine ranks 2, second only to Earpeggio (iTunes Search API, 11-07). This suggests store search is now sending it traffic too (rating count and tap-through rate are helping).

### 4. Where users come from

1. **Its own TikTok (confirmed, the main driver)** . The turning point was 10-06's "One of these trombones is out of tune" (170k plays): a row of identical-looking lemurs hold the same instrument, one is out of tune, viewers guess which, then the answer is revealed, and the caption asks people to comment "2/2" or "3/3". After that only the instrument (oboe, tuba, bass clarinet, bagpipes, kalimba) and setting (subway, church, Oktoberfest, pirate ship, dragon lair) change, and each is a new episode. Tags stay fixed at #bandkids #marchingband #eartraining, aimed at US middle and high school band and orchestra students. Instruments requested in the comments get made into the next video, and the caption thanks the commenter (e.g., "huge shoutout to @chrissstopjer for the idea").

2. **Serialized storyline to build followers (confirmed)** . Starting 10-22, a storyline was added: the out-of-tune C gets kicked out of the band, locked in a dungeon, escapes with Nocturne, the queen gives chase, and the clown Bobo pops up now and then. The question is still the same, but fans now have a reason to keep coming back. Starting 11-01, they also post "dev logs" explaining why the paywall changed.

3. **Fan remixes (confirmed)** . Under #learnsine on TikTok there are many fan edits and drawings: @toast3xoticbutterz "justice for C chat #nichefandom" 210k plays, @sleepysan_ "#DRUMMERC" 190k plays, plus dedicated fan accounts like @cfromlearnsine and @learnsine_ccc, and people calling themselves the "learn.sine fandom". On Reddit r/isitAI someone asked whether its art style was AI-generated.

4. **The same videos are distributed to Instagram Reels and YouTube Shorts (confirmed)** . Instagram @eartraining.games has 96k followers, YouTube 18.6k subscribers. In App Store reviews compiled by stringers.io, some users say they came from Insta and YouTube Shorts.

5. **"Ads" mentioned in App Store reviews (unconfirmed as paid ads)** . A US review says: "I came from all the advertisements on TikTok". But none of the TikTok posts we pulled are labeled as ads; the Meta ad library (metaads) shows no ads for learnsine or this app's landing page; the TikTok European ad library has no mapping records either. The most likely explanation is users mistaking organically surfaced videos for ads. Whether they used Spark Ads to boost organic posts can't be seen from the outside.

6. **Platform expansion hit at the right moment (confirmed)** . 10-04 it came to Android, and two days later the format took off. Android caught that wave, reaching 28k installs in about a month.

7. **In-product acquisition (confirmed to exist, effectiveness unknown)** : Sine Circles friend circles (10-12 launched, friends answer questions together to water a tree), Encore Family invite links, and an early-access application for a classroom version for music teachers ([learnsine.com/teachers](https://learnsine.com/teachers)).

**Not found** : press coverage, discussion on X (x-radar returned 60 results for "learnsine" in the past 0 days, and searching "Sine ear training" returned nothing relevant), Product Hunt / HN, public revenue. The only in-depth breakdown is stringers.io's 11-08 article ([link](https://stringers.io/en/apps/play_com.maoi.sine.md)), which is our own site.

### 5. Why people stay and pay

- US App Store reviews (11-07) mostly praise three things: "the cheaper price point", "does not ask you to pay… does not have ads", and "the mascot is adorable". Some say their favorite part is "guessing which band member is out of tune".

- Almost all the negative feedback targets the paywall: "the MOST important features… locked behind their subscription wall". The founder replied personally: these features were only proofs of concept, and intervals and chords would be reworked and made free, with intro theory, rhythm, and notation added later. Several later versions did move intro lessons into the free tier. **By replying to reviews and shipping updates quickly, they turned complaints into a roadmap** .

- Risks: most people coming in from videos are teenagers, who may play without paying. Neither platform has entered the overall Top Grossing chart, so conversion and revenue are unknown. TikTok weekly plays dropped from 9M to 3M; if the new rhythm mechanics don't hold attention, growth will keep falling.

### 6. Differentiation, and whether that's why it took off

- Feature-wise, it isn't differentiated: pitch recognition, intervals, chords, absolute pitch, instrument timbres are all in established apps, some more complete.

- The real differentiation has three layers, and each is why it broke out:
    1. **The gameplay is the content** . Out of Tune's screen is already vertical, with a row of characters, and you can answer just by listening. Clip it and it's a short video with no extra editing. What viewers play in the video, they can keep playing in the app after downloading. Trill hiring creators to talk on camera or Pitch Trainer buying Meta ads can't do "watching the video is already playing the product".
    2. **Character IP plus serialization** . Lemur Sine, C, Nocturne, Bobo, and the queen turn a quiz account into a series you can follow and remix. Pitch Master can copy the format, but not the fandom already active in the comments.
    3. **Pricing and posture run the opposite way** . Competing new apps tend to use "quiz onboarding plus a $7.99/week hard paywall". Sine charges $14.99/year, has no ads, and the free tier is enough, and the founder replies to comments personally. That's why teen users are willing to give 5 stars and help spread it.

- Behind it is execution speed: roughly 15 updates a month, 2–5 posts a day on TikTok, and instruments requested in comments show up in videos and the app the next day.

### VII. Copycats

- **Pitch Master** (@learnperfectpitch, about 5.7K followers): from late October it posted "PIANO EDITION — Find the Imposter. Four moles. One is out of tune. Three rounds" and "CELLO EDITION Three rounds", with "XX EDITION" titles nearly identical to Sine's, getting 500 to 27k plays per video.

- **@absolutepitchtrainer** (394 followers): starting 11-04 it posted "One is out of tune 👂 Musicians only! Trumpet / Flute / Soprano edition. Comment how many you got out of 3", getting a few hundred plays per video.

- No copycat has yet built real play counts.

### VIII. What to take from it

- Start by designing a core mechanic that you can **cut straight into 15-second guessing clips** (same visuals, swap one variable and it's a new episode), so the short video and the product are one and the same.

- In the first two weeks or so, test several question types, lock in whichever one breaks 100k per video, and post daily; turn instruments requested in comments into the next episode and name the commenter in the caption.

- Once you have a stable audience, add storyline to the characters, turning a quiz account into a serial that fans can remix.

- Target a niche already active on TikTok precisely (here #bandkids), and use an in-group joke ("someone in your section is always flat").

- Low price, a generous free tier, no ads, and rating prompts shown at moments of user delight; the founder replies to bad reviews personally and ships fixes quickly.

- iOS first, then Android, but have the second platform ready before the spike arrives.

### 9. What I'm still unsure about

- Revenue and conversion: has not entered the overall Top Grossing chart, only appeared at the tail of education top-grossing charts in a few small countries; AppGoblin estimates <$10K/month, unreliable.

- Who the founder is and how big the team is: "Ethan Liao is a San Francisco high school jazz pianist" is only a strong lead; Apple's individual developer accounts require adult status, so it could be a parent or someone else holding the account (speculation).

- Whether they pay to boost organic posts (Spark Ads) or run US TikTok ads: neither the European ad library nor the Meta library shows anything, but US TikTok ads aren't visible from the outside.

- When the Instagram 96k follower count was scraped, and how many downloads Reels brought, are both unclear.

- After TikTok plays cooled in November, iOS rating growth picked up on 11-07 and 11-08 (+63 / +26 in a single day), and the number of charting countries rose from 8–12 in late October to 36. The likely cause is 0.22's new version adding the Round the Fire rhythm game and new lessons, or rising store search rankings, **unverified** .

- Whether the art is AI-generated: someone suspected so; unverified.

### Sources

- appstore database (app_day / app_profile / chart_rank, 2026-10-28 to 11-08); googleplay database (app_day / app_profile, 10-29 to 11-08); metaads database, advertiser table; tiktokads database, adv_map table.

- iTunes Lookup / Search API (2026-11-07); App Store review page [apps.apple.com/us/app/sine-ear-training-games/id6809608874?s…](https://apps.apple.com/us/app/sine-ear-training-games/id6809608874?see-all=reviews)

- TikHub: @learn.sine profile and 106 videos; keyword searches for "who is out of tune", "ear training challenge", "learnsine"; @learnperfectpitch and @absolutepitchtrainer videos (2026-11-08).

- Website [learnsine.com/](https://learnsine.com/), /about, /releases, /terms, /teachers; Google Play page [play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.maoi.sine](https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.maoi.sine)

- stringers.io:[stringers.io/apps/play_com.maoi.sine.html](https://stringers.io/en/apps/play_com.maoi.sine.md) , [stringers.io/m/033.html](https://stringers.io/en/m/033.md)

- SFist [sfist.com/2025/04/18/sf-high-school-freshman-to-be-honored-a…](https://sfist.com/2025/04/18/sf-high-school-freshman-to-be-honored-at-the-lincoln-center-after-winning-prestigious-national-competition/) ;TEDx [www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnDTX94hj40](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RnDTX94hj40)

- AppGoblin [appgoblin.info/apps/6809608874](https://appgoblin.info/apps/6809608874) ;chartoo [hk.chartoo.com/itunes/app/6809608874-sine-ear-training-games](https://hk.chartoo.com/itunes/app/6809608874-sine-ear-training-games)

- x-radar search (last 60 days, "learnsine", "Sine ear training").

This article was written by AI from public data and the data we collect daily. Numbers are sourced, and inferences are labeled.
