
"SketchyBar without the scripting": two Swiss developers posted 5 times in 9 days and pushed a Mac menu bar to 179 stars
What it is A free, open-source Mac app that replaces the system menu bar at the top of the screen with a bar you can theme and drag widgets onto. It shows tiling window manager workspaces, with no scripting required like SketchyBar.
Why it took off The author used AI coding agents to make over 700 commits in a month and built a more complete GUI version than the alternatives. Then, over 9 days, they posted personally on r/unixporn, Product Hunt, r/SwiftUI, r/coolgithubprojects and r/MacOS, pitching it differently for each community. Nearly all the stars came in the last three days of posting.
BHow you can copy it Don't build another Mac menu bar. Copy the playbook: find a geek tool that only works through config files and scripts, make a version with a GUI, themes and a store, generate demo assets with code, then post on Reddit with a different pitch for each subreddit, reply to comments yourself, and ship a new version the same day.
211 stars · +7 in the last 164 days
StableBar is a free, open-source macOS menu bar replacement written in Swift. The author pitches it as "SketchyBar with a GUI." A month after the repo was created, it has 179 stars. 123 of them came in the three days from 11-13 to 11-15, exactly when the author was posting on Reddit back to back. The product is more complete than its alternatives, but when stars arrive and how many depends on the posts. This playbook doesn't require a readership up front, so anyone can follow it. The catch is the ceiling: the most popular project in this niche has only about 10,000 stars.
A Saturday afternoon post
2026 Nov 14 was a Saturday, and r/MacOS allows developers to share their own projects on this day (Developer Saturday). At UTC 14:12, the account owiren posted "My friend and I made a free and open-source menu bar alternative." The post covered a few things: free, open source, signed and notarized, collects no data, installable with one brew command. It got 201 upvotes and 55 comments, and the author replied to nearly every one.
owiren is Sebastien Graf (Seb-GRAF on GitHub). He's a former frontend developer at Swiss digital agency Liip. The "friend" in the post is Steve Mendes Reis (M4n0x), a software engineer in Lausanne. That day the repo gained 45 stars, its biggest single day so far, and the next day added another +43 (Trendshift daily data).
The comments weren't all praise. Some said "complete waste of space," and someone asked, "Does your friend's name happen to be Claude? Lol." That last one got to the heart of it, as covered below.
What it is
A native Mac app under the MIT license that requires macOS 14 or later and Apple silicon. Once installed, it draws its own bar across the top of the screen that can replace or cover the system menu bar. Widgets on the bar include workspaces, the current app, the app menu, calendar, battery, sound, network, CPU and memory, and now playing. Clicking each widget opens a panel with charts and controls.
Its main difference from the long-established SketchyBar is how it's configured:
- No scripting required. You can configure it in the settings window, or right-click "Edit Bar in Place" and drag things directly on the bar. For manual edits there's
~/.config/stablebar/config.json, with autocomplete. - Ships with 7 themes and a setup wizard, plus a store for widgets and themes. The store currently has 12 packages, all written by the author, such as Claude Code and Codex usage quotas, GitHub notifications, and Homebrew pending updates. Before you install a package, it lists which commands it runs, which domains it connects to, and which permissions it needs.
- Any script that outputs text or JSON can be used as a widget, so existing SketchyBar scripts can be moved over.
- It reads workspaces from the tiling window managers AeroSpace, yabai, OmniWM and Rift. If you don't run one, it reads macOS's built-in Spaces.
The website is stablebar.app. You can install via DMG or through the author's self-hosted Homebrew tap, and Sparkle handles automatic updates.
Back to the question: was it written by Claude?
Pretty much. The repo contains CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md and a .claude/ directory, and in the r/unixporn post the author wrote "I build it with a lot of help from AI coding agents." The two people made 334 and 385 commits respectively in one month. Trendshift counts 230 merged PRs over 25 days. Between 11-14 and 11-15 alone, 6 betas of v0.16.0 were released (GitHub Releases).
That speed has a payoff: when someone in the Reddit comments asks for a feature, it becomes an issue and a beta the same day. The author could confidently write "We react fast to feedback" because of this speed.
How the stars came in: each post produced a jump the next day
| Date | Stars gained that day | What happened that day |
|---|---|---|
| 10-15 | — | Repo created, 4 releases shipped the same day |
| 10-26 ~ 10-28 | +3 per day | A co-author submitted a PR to awesome-mac (a Mac app list with 118k stars), and it was merged (10-26) |
| 11-06 | +5 | Posted a full Gruvbox-themed desktop on r/unixporn, 187 upvotes; the bar was just one item in the config list |
| 11-10 | +5 | Submitted a self-nomination to Ruan Yifeng's "Tech Enthusiast Weekly" and wasn't picked up |
| 11-11 | +11 | Launched on Product Hunt, with the author as hunter, ranking #18 that day with 87 votes |
| 11-13 | +35 | Posted a technical write-up on r/SwiftUI (58 upvotes), then three hours later another post on r/coolgithubprojects (25 upvotes) |
| 11-14 | +45 | The r/MacOS post (201 upvotes, 55 comments) |
| 11-15 | +43 | Afterglow of the r/MacOS post |
Sources: Trendshift daily stars (UTC), individual post pages, GitHub. As of 11-16, a total of 179 stars and 11 forks.
Between posts, it gained only 0 to 3 stars a day. The curve follows the posting times exactly, and no one else seems to have amplified it: it never hit Hacker News, got no media coverage, has no discussion on X, and nothing on TikTok. The only third party is an AI account on Instagram and Facebook that reposts trending GitHub projects automatically. It posted an intro video for 11-14, which got 3,900 views on Facebook. These accounts repost whatever is trending, so the video only appeared after the project was already hot.
You can estimate real users from download counts: the stable DMG has been downloaded about 870 times (GitHub Releases), plus Homebrew installs you can't see. The number of people who've actually installed it is probably a few hundred to just over a thousand, the same order of magnitude as the star count (an inference).
One product, a different story for each subreddit
This is what's most worth learning from StableBar. The same person posted to 4 Reddit communities in 9 days, and each post was written for what that community likes:
- r/unixporn (the desktop showcase subreddit): no product pitch, just a whole desktop setup, with the bar mentioned as the author's own creation only in the last line, which keeps it within the rules. It got 187 upvotes, but most people here use Linux, so it brought only 5 stars.
- r/SwiftUI (developers): written as "a few things I learned while building it," covering how NSPanel wraps NSHostingView, morphing animations between popups, a pitfall with
.glassEffect, and how to have the app render README screenshots off-screen. - r/coolgithubprojects: the first line speaks directly to the established option: "If you've seen those SketchyBar setups on r/unixporn and wanted one which is easier to use and setup."
- r/MacOS (everyday Mac users): timed for Developer Saturday, focusing on free, private, secure, one-line install.
The other three "wait for people to come" channels each brought only single-digit stars: the awesome-mac listing, the #18 Product Hunt spot, and the newsletter self-nomination. For open-source dev tools, Product Hunt votes barely convert into stars.
One easily overlooked point: the demo assets are excellent. The GIFs in the README (6 of them) and the website visuals are rendered off-screen by the app itself from scene files, with consistent proportions and a clock frozen at the same time. Every PR also automatically produces before-and-after comparison images. The website is interactive, with lighting that follows the mouse. Someone on r/MacOS commented, "the website is one of the most creative and amazing websites i have ever seen." The author is a frontend developer by trade, so this is his strength.
Why now
Tiling window managers have taken off on Mac over the past couple of years: AeroSpace has 23.7k stars, and OmniWM, created in October 2025, already has 3,600 stars. Many people who use tiling window managers want a Linux-style status bar. Someone on r/unixporn noted, "been seeing a slight increase in macos posts recently." macOS 26 added the Liquid Glass effect, and StableBar followed suit.
Until now, if you wanted a bar like this, your main option was SketchyBar, which requires writing shell or Lua scripts. StableBar can explain itself in one line: SketchyBar without the scripting. That line makes sense in any post.
There's pushback too. On r/SwiftUI someone wrote "'Any script is a widget.' I really hate AI bro speak," and others found the promo video ugly. Another person pointed out that third-party app icons in the system menu bar can only appear as app icons on its bar, a limitation of the macOS API that can't be worked around.
Who's competing for this spot
| Project | Scale | How StableBar differs |
|---|---|---|
| SketchyBar | 12,622 stars, 7 days +34 | The de facto standard, with lots of community configs, but requires writing shell / Lua scripts |
| simple-bar | 1,628 stars, barely growing | Install Übersicht first, then write it in JS/CSS |
| barik | 520 stars, 2026-01 no updates since | The closest native alternative in this area, with fewer features; it's been discontinued |
| zebar | 3,125 star | Cross-platform, mainly targets Windows, built with web tech |
| omacosy | 715 star | A full omarchy-style Mac desktop; the bar is just one piece of it |
| Rill | 3 star | 10-16 created the repo; it's a native Swift bar with a plugin system. 11-09 posted it to r/unixporn and got only 22 upvotes |
| Ice, Thaw, Bartender | Ice 30k stars, Thaw 12.7k stars; Bartender is paid | A menu bar manager that only hides and organizes system icons. It doesn't replace the whole bar, and has far more users, but the need is different |
| Built into macOS 26 | All Macs | You can adjust transparency and pick which system controls show. You can't change the theme, add script widgets, or show tiling workspaces |
Source: GitHub, 11-16.
"Replacing the whole bar" is a niche need in the Mac ricing community. SketchyBar, the most popular tool there, gains only a few dozen stars a week. Native GUI alternatives already exist: barik, Rill, and Aegis, none of which took off. StableBar is the most complete and the most aggressively promoted of them. I haven't seen anyone build on it yet.
If it were you
My take: Don't build another Mac menu bar. StableBar already holds the spot for "a GUI SketchyBar," and it ships several versions a day. What's worth learning is the playbook: take a power-user tool that only works through config files and scripts, build a version with a GUI, themes, and a store, then post it to the matching Reddit communities, with a different pitch for each. This playbook doesn't require an audience first.
Who it's for: Developers who can do front-end work and make good-looking demo material; people who are already part of a tinkering community (Linux desktops, terminals, editors, keyboards) and know where those users get stuck; and anyone who can keep up a one-version-a-day pace with an AI coding agent.
Who it's not for: Anyone hoping for thousands or tens of thousands of stars. Two people made 700 commits in a month and posted in 5 places, and got 179 stars. These communities are small, so the ceiling is roughly the star count of the established tool in that niche.
How to do it:
- Pick targets like this: tools with lots of community configs that beginners can't copy-paste into working setups. Most r/unixporn users run Linux. Before going further, check whether good GUI config tools already exist for things like Waybar on Hyprland and other Linux desktop widgets (inference, not verified).
- State it in one line: "X without writing scripts." Put that sentence on the first screen of the README, with a demo you rendered yourself.
- Generate demo assets with code: render screenshots and GIFs from scene files, and use the same set for the README, the website, and Product Hunt. Every change automatically produces before/after images.
- Build in compatibility: old tools' scripts can be used directly as widgets, so existing users can switch without rewriting anything.
How to get users: Follow their order. First post a complete config in the communities where people share finished setups, and mention the product only at the end. Then write a developer-focused post like "Things I learned building it" and post directly to r/coolgithubprojects and similar places, benchmarking against the established tools. Finally, on the day a community allows self-promotion, pitch it to general users around free, privacy, and one-line install. Reply to every comment yourself, and turn feedback into issues and new releases the same day. Submit to Product Hunt and awesome lists too, but don't expect them to bring many stars.
When to get in: Tiling window managers and ricing are still growing, and they've only recently picked up on the Mac (inference). StableBar's spot is already taken. If you build in a different community, whoever ships a complete GUI version first gets to own the line "X without writing scripts."
What would show I'm wrong: If StableBar keeps gaining stars after it stops posting, for example if the repo passes 60 days old and keeps growing after it hits Swift's trending list, that would mean these tools spread on their own and are worth scaling up. On the other hand, if it stalls at two or three hundred stars, the community is too small, and a round of posts is all it will ever get.
Research notes: competitor table, acquisition evidence, full research report
- Competitors
Name Where Launched Scale How it differs from this one FelixKratz/SketchyBar Open source 2021-08 12,622 stars, 7 days +34 SketchyBar requires writing shell/Lua scripts for config. StableBar uses a GUI plus JSON, with built-in themes, a setup wizard, and a store. It's also compatible with script widgets. Jean-Tinland/simple-bar Open source 2020-05 1,628 stars, barely growing It's a plugin for Übersicht and is written in JS/CSS. StableBar is a standalone native app. mocki-toki/barik Open source 2025-02 520 stars, no updates since 2026-01 The closest in direction, but fewer features and no longer maintained. StableBar has a store, in-bar editing, and is shipping fast. paulsp94/omacosy Open source 2026-08 715 star It's a full omarchy-style desktop, and the bar is only one part of it. glzr-io/zebar Open source 2023-06 3,125 star Cross-platform and mainly aimed at Windows, built with web tech. AleckAstan/Rill Open source 2026-10-16 3 star A native Swift bar with a plugin SDK that launched around the same time. It never took off. jordanbaird/Ice / thaw-app/Thaw / Bartender Open source 2023 / 2026-01 / long-established commercial tools Ice 30k stars, Thaw 12.7k stars; Bartender is paid A menu bar manager: it only hides and organizes system icons and doesn't replace the whole bar. Different need. macOS 26 transparent menu bar and Control Center customization Big-company features 2025 All Macs You can only adjust transparency and pick system controls. You can't change the theme, add script widgets, or show tiling workspaces. - Where users come from
- Verified Reddit posts by community (the author, owiren, posted these personally): r/unixporn 11-06 187 upvotes; r/SwiftUI 11-13 09:22 58 upvotes; r/coolgithubprojects 11-13 12:36 25 upvotes; r/MacOS 11-14 14:12 201 upvotes 55 comments (Developer Saturday). Matches Trendshift's daily +35 / +45 / +43.
- Verified Product Hunt launch by the team: 11-11 Seb was the hunter himself, ranked #18, 87 votes, +11 stars that day.
- Verified self-submitted to awesome lists and newsletters: jaywcjlove/awesome-mac, PR 7abe353 "Add StableBar to Menu Bar Tools (#3909)" by Steve Mendes Reis, merged 10-26, then +3 a day for three days in a row. Self-nomination issue #13257 to 阮一峰's weekly (11-10, not picked up)
- Verified Third-party AI repost accounts and auto-generated directory pages: GithubSignals IG/FB videos (3.9K views on FB), plus directory pages like opendmg, openmacapps, macmenubar, alternativeto, and reporank.
- Inference 10-26 Chinese social mentions logged by Trendshift: "StableBar - a customizable menu bar alternative…" The original post hasn't been found.
Why Seb-GRAF/StableBar took off
Data as of 2026-11-16 (GitHub API, Trendshift, and Reddit post data are all read as of this day). The "today 2026-11-07" in why.md is earlier than the data cutoff, so the figures here use the date the data actually reflects.
Bottom line
StableBar is an open-source macOS menu bar replacement written in Swift. It calls itself "a GUI SketchyBar." Calling it something that "took off" is a stretch: it had 179 stars as of 11-16. Those stars didn't grow organically. Two Swiss developers got them by posting personally, one community at a time, over 9 days from 11-06 to 11-14, and on Product Hunt: r/unixporn for desktop showcases, Product Hunt, r/SwiftUI for the technical write-up, r/coolgithubprojects, and r/MacOS for Developer Saturday. Each post added a jump in stars the next day. The biggest day (+45) came from the r/MacOS post (201 upvotes). The product itself is genuinely different: no scripting, configuration in a settings window, drag widgets directly onto the bar, themes and a widget store, and polished demo GIFs. That's what lets posts convert into stars, but the traffic came from posting.
1. What it is
- A native macOS app written in Swift, AppKit and SwiftUI, MIT-licensed. Once installed, it draws its own bar across the top of the screen, which can replace or cover the system menu bar. The bar holds widgets for Spaces, the current app, the app menu, calendar, battery, sound, network, CPU/memory, now playing and more. Click any of them for a popup with charts and controls.
- Works with the tiling window managers AeroSpace, yabai, OmniWM and Rift, and reads macOS's built-in Spaces when none of them are installed.
- There are three ways to configure it: the settings window, right-click "Edit Bar in Place" to drag things directly on the bar, or edit
~/.config/stablebar/config.json(with JSON Schema autocomplete). Any script that outputs text or JSON can become a widget, which is the same idea SketchyBar uses. - Ships with 7 themes, plus a component/theme store
Seb-GRAF/stablebar-packages. There are 12 packages so far, all written by the author themselves, such as Now Playing, AI usage (Claude Code / Codex quota), GitHub notifications, and Homebrew updates pending. Before installing, it lists the commands the package runs, the domains it connects to, and the permissions it needs. - Requires macOS 14 or later on Apple silicon. Install via DMG or the self-hosted Homebrew tap (
seb-graf/tap/stablebar). Auto-updates through Sparkle. Signed and notarized, and collects no data. - Sources: README, official site stablebar.app, author's project page
Who built it: Sebastien Graf (Seb-GRAF), a front-end developer at Swiss digital agency Liip, with 137 GitHub followers, and previously the author of tailwind-helper (134 stars). The other main author is Steve Mendes Reis (M4n0x), a software engineer in Lausanne with 22 followers. In one month they made 334 and 385 commits respectively. The third contributor, Jonathanm10, also works at Liip. It's a side project by two or three colleagues, with no company or venture capital behind it.
How it's built: the repo has CLAUDE.md, AGENTS.md, .claude/, .agents/ and .coderabbit.yaml. In its r/unixporn post, the author says: "I build it with a lot of help from AI coding agents". Trendshift counts 230 merged PRs in 25 days, and GitHub releases shipped dozens of betas in a month, several a day (the v0.13.0 through v0.16.0 betas all went out between 11-11 and 11-15).
2. Growth data
| Date (UTC) | Trendshift stars today | What happened the same day |
|---|---|---|
| 10-15 | — | Built the database, shipped v0.1.1 through v0.4.0 the same day |
| 10-26 ~ 10-28 | +3 / +3 / +3 | 10-26 M4n0x submitted StableBar to jaywcjlove/awesome-mac (118k stars) himself, and it was merged as "Add StableBar to Menu Bar Tools (#3909)"; Trendshift logged a Chinese social mention the same day |
| 11-06 | +5 | owiren (= Seb) posted "[AeroSpace] Gruvbox, but make it 70s" on r/unixporn, with 187 upvotes and 5 comments, and linked the repo at the end of the post |
| 11-10 | +5 | Seb submitted an open-source self-promotion issue to Ruan Yifeng's weekly (#13257, not picked up in issue 419) |
| 11-11 | +11 | Launched on Product Hunt, #18 of the day, 85–87 upvotes, 3 comments, Seb hunted it himself |
| 11-12 | +6 | — |
| 11-13 | +35 | r/SwiftUI technical sharing post (09:22,58 upvotes, 9 comments); r/coolgithubprojects (12:36,25 upvotes, 4 comments) |
| 11-14 | +45 | r/MacOS "My friend and I made a free and open-source menu bar alternative" (14:12,201 upvotes, 55 comments, 87% upvoted, charted in the Developer Saturday thread); the same day GithubSignals posted an AI-generated intro video on IG/FB (3.9K FB views, 26 reactions) |
| 11-15 | +43 | Afterglow of the r/MacOS post |
| 11-16 | +2 (the day isn't over) | — |
- Our GitHub repo data card: 11-03 22 stars, 11-12 47,11-13 51,11-14 82,11-15 124,11-16 171 (the snapshot date is one day behind UTC). gain_7d = 141. 11-16 Later, the GitHub API reported 179 stars and 11 forks.
- Downloads (GitHub release asset counts): the stable DMGs total about 870 downloads (v0.15.0 278, v0.14.0 173, v0.13.0 93, v0.9.0 92, v0.11.0 88 ...); the appcast was fetched about 2100 times. That's Sparkle update-check requests, not unique users. Homebrew tap installs aren't visible. So the real install base is probably a few hundred to a bit over a thousand.
- Of the 11 forks, 2 are the author's own (M4n0x, Jonathanm10). The rest are personal forks with 0 stars each, none renamed into separate projects.
- Trendshift: "Not in the Trendshift top 25 in this period". The repo is under 60 days old, so it can't make GitHub trending.
- Hacker News: our hackernews database shows no StableBar posts, and no SketchyBar posts in 2026 years. X: x-radar shows 0 posts each for StableBar and SketchyBar. The only sighting was
@bot_unixpornauto-reposting the unixporn thread. TikTok: a TikHub search for "StableBar mac" returned 0 results.
Takeaway: nearly all the stars came in the three days 11-13 to 11-15, the same three days the author posted across Reddit, and the timing matches down to the hour. In the 3 weeks before, it was only 0–3 a day.
3. Where users came from (growth tactics)
- The author posted to each subreddit personally (confirmed, and the main driver). The same account, owiren, posted to 4 subreddits over 9 days, with a different pitch for each:
- r/unixporn: no product pitch. It shared a full Gruvbox desktop setup list, with the bar as one item, and only the last line said "the bar is my own project", which fits the subreddit rules. It got 187 upvotes, but the audience there is mostly Linux users, so it brought only +5 stars.
- r/SwiftUI: a technical post titled "things I learned while building". It covered NSPanel plus NSHostingView, morphing transitions between popovers, the view-identity pitfall with
.glassEffect, and rendering README screenshots off-screen in the app itself for before/after CI comparisons. It used the subreddit's Promotion flair. - r/coolgithubprojects: opened with "If you've seen those SketchyBar setups on r/unixporn and wanted one which is easier to use and setup".
- r/MacOS: posted during Developer Saturday, titled "My friend and I made…". It emphasized free, open source, signed and notarized, no data collection, and a one-line brew install, and the author replied to every comment. This was the biggest wave.
- Self-submitted to Product Hunt (confirmed). 11-11, ranked #18, 87 votes, brought only +11 stars. PH converts weakly for open-source dev tools.
- Self-submitted to lists (confirmed). awesome-mac was a PR the co-author opened and it was merged (10-26). The Ruan Yifeng weekly was a self-nomination issue and was not accepted. The daily gains of +3 from 10-26 to 10-28 line up with the awesome-mac listing. abordage/awesome-mac (37 stars), opendmg.app, openmacapps.com, macmenubar.com, alternativeto, hunted.space, reporank, and upstar.dev are automated or semi-automated directories, so I can't tell which the author submitted.
- Third-party repost accounts (confirmed, small volume). GithubSignals (labeled "AI content" on Instagram) posted an intro video on IG and FB, with 3.9K FB views. These accounts pick projects automatically based on GitHub buzz, so they're a result of the buzz, not its source.
- One Chinese social mention (unverified). Trendshift logged one Chinese post, 10-26, reading "StableBar - customizable menu bar alternative with themes, widgets, popover panels, and AeroSpace, yabai, or OmniWM workspace support". It looks like an automated post from a GitHub recommendation account, with very little impact.
- Not found: paid promotion, KOLs, YouTube reviews, press coverage, HN.
4. Competitors
| Name | Where | Launched | Scale | How it differs from StableBar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FelixKratz/SketchyBar | Open source | 2021-08 | 12,622 stars, 7 days +34 | Configured with shell or Lua scripts. The learning curve is steep, but the ecosystem and community configs are huge. StableBar uses a GUI plus JSON config, positioned as "SketchyBar without writing scripts". |
| Jean-Tinland/simple-bar | Open source (an Übersicht plugin) | 2020-05 | 1,628 stars, barely growing | You need to install Übersicht first and write in JS/CSS. StableBar is a standalone native app. |
| mocki-toki/barik | Open source | 2025-02 | 520 stars, no updates since 2026-01 | Closest in direction (a native menu bar replacement, with yabai/AeroSpace support), but fewer features and no longer maintained. StableBar has a store, themes, and in-bar editing, and it's iterating fast. |
| paulsp94/omacosy | Open source | 2026-08 | 715 star | A full omarchy-style desktop (tiling plus bar), with the bar as only one part. |
| glzr-io/zebar | Open source | 2023-06 | 3,125 star | Cross-platform and mainly aimed at Windows, built with web tech. |
| cmacrae/spacebar | Open source | 2020-03 | 1,356 stars, no longer updated | A minimal bar for yabai, unmaintained for a long time. |
| AleckAstan/Rill | Open source | 2026-10-16 | 3 star | Others were building at the same time: a Swift native bar with a plugin SDK got only 22 upvotes for its r/unixporn post, 11-09. |
| CCMurphy-dev/Aegis, AeroSpaceBar | Open source | 2026 | 46 stars, etc. | Menu bar and notch plus workspace panel only, low completeness. |
| jordanbaird/Ice, thaw-app/Thaw, dwarvesf/hidden, Bartender (paid) | Open source / commercial | 2019–2026 | Ice 30k, Thaw 12.7k, Hidden 15.4k stars. Bartender is the paid veteran. | This category is "menu bar managers": they hide and organize system menu bar icons and don't replace the whole bar. The audience is much larger, but the need is different. |
| SwiftBar / xbar | Open source | 2020 / 2013 | 4.8k / 18k star | Pipes script output into one slot of the system menu bar without replacing the bar. |
| Built into macOS (26 Tahoe onward has a transparent menu bar and customizable Control Center items). | Big-company features | 2025 | All Macs | Only transparency and picking system controls. Can't change themes, add script widgets, or show tiling workspaces (not verified item by item). |
Landscape: "replace the whole bar" is a niche need in the macOS ricing community. SketchyBar is the de facto standard at 12.6k stars, but it gains only dozens per week. New native GUI alternatives (barik, Rill, Aegis) haven't taken off. StableBar is the most complete and the most actively promoted of them.
5. Why it took off
- It found a specific, easy-to-state pain point: SketchyBar can only be configured with shell or Lua. The original line was "If you've seen those SketchyBar setups on r/unixporn and wanted one which is easier to use and setup". In r/MacOS, the author explained the rewrite: SketchyBar works poorly with window managers, often needs a config reload, and its animations and popovers feel clunky.
- Polished demo assets that spread well by themselves: the 6 GIFs in the README and the website were rendered off-screen by the app itself from scene files, with consistent proportions and the clock fixed to one time. The website is interactive (lights follow the mouse). A comment on r/MacOS said "the website is one of the most creative and amazing websites i have ever seen". The author comes from frontend, and that strength shows here.
- The author posted to each subreddit personally, with a pitch tailored to what each community likes (see section 3). The star curve over three days matches the posting times one to one.
- Fast iteration with AI coding agents: over 700 commits in a month, 230 PRs, dozens of releases. Feature requests from Reddit users (like the 6 items Anton-Demkin listed on r/coolgithubprojects) became issues the same day, and betas shipped the same day. The "We react fast to feedback" line in the comments is credible because of that speed.
- Riding the macOS ricing and tiling window manager wave: after AeroSpace (23.7k stars) and OmniWM (3.6k stars, created 2025-10) took off over the past year or two, a group of Mac users started wanting Linux-style bars. A comment on r/unixporn said "been seeing a slight increase in macos posts recently". StableBar supports 4 window managers at once and added macOS 26's Liquid Glass effect.
The downside: plenty of criticism in the comments. r/SwiftUI had "'Any script is a widget.' I really hate AI bro speak", "The video is so off-putting", and "looks like shit". r/MacOS had "complete waste of space" and "Does your friend's name happen to be Claude? Lol." Some also pointed out that system menu bar icons can only show the app icon, a limit of the macOS API. The 54 open issues are mostly the author's own task list (per the author's count: M4n0x 23, Seb 11, Jonathanm10 6, Ergotomy 6, others 1 each).
6. Differentiation, and whether it's the reason it took off
- Differentiation: it does everything SketchyBar does, plus three things SketchyBar doesn't have: a graphical settings UI with drag-in-bar editing, 7 built-in themes and a setup wizard, and a widget store with permission notes. Against native alternatives like barik, it wins on completeness and iteration speed.
- Why it's taking off: differentiation is what lets a post turn into stars. "SketchyBar without scripts" is easy to say in one line, which suits posting. But when the stars come is entirely driven by posting: the awesome-mac listing, Product Hunt, and other "submit and wait" channels bring single digits a day. So it's the product × the distribution playbook, and distribution sets the timing and the volume. At this point the scale is tiny (179 stars, a few hundred downloads), and it's still far from breaking out.
7. How many people know it / has anyone copied it
- Visibility: almost nobody knows yet. 179 stars. No HN post, no press coverage, no X discussion (x-radar shows 0 posts). What's visible is a few Reddit threads, a #18 finish on PH, an AI repost account's video, and some automated directory pages. No revenue, and nothing public to report.
- Copycats: none. AleckAstan/Rill (10-16 created, 3 stars), which launched at the same time, is a separate project, not a copy.
8. What others can borrow
- Turn a CLI-only or config-file-only dev tool into a GUI with a store. The value can be stated in one line: "X without writing scripts".
- Same product, different Reddit angle: showcase the finished look (unixporn), talk the tech pain (SwiftUI), compare with the old guard (coolgithubprojects), talk usage and privacy (MacOS), and post on each sub's self-promo day (Developer Saturday). The author replies in the comments and turns feedback into issues on the spot.
- Let the product render its own demo assets (scene file plus off-screen screenshots). README, website and PH all use the same set, and CI auto-generates before/after images on every PR.
- Ship several betas a day with an AI coding agent, and make fast responses the selling point.
- Limits: macOS-native, needs signing and notarization, and the audience is a small crowd of ricing and tiling window manager fans. The ceiling looks like SketchyBar's 10k-odd stars. There's no monetization path (MIT, free, no accounts).
9. Still unclear
- The stargazers endpoint returns 404, so the starring accounts can't be checked one by one. Judging from how the curve lines up with post timing and the forks look normal, it doesn't look bought, but I didn't verify each account.
- I couldn't find the original post for the Chinese mention on 10-26.
- Homebrew tap install counts and how many people are still actually using it aren't visible.
- Whether 11-16 keeps growing on its own: once the r/MacOS bump fades, it depends on the next post or whether a big account reshares it. Once the repo hits 60 days old (around 12-14) it could make Swift's trending page.
Sources
- GitHub API:
repos/Seb-GRAF/StableBar(stars / forks / release downloads / contributors / issues / fork list),users/Seb-GRAF,users/M4n0x,repos/jaywcjlove/awesome-mac/commits(7abe353,2026-10-26),repos/ruanyf/weekly/issues/13257 - Trendshift:trendshift.io/repositories/320583
- Reddit (post data pulled via ScrapeCreators): r/unixporn www.reddit.com/r/unixporn/comments/1xpb271/; r/SwiftUI www.reddit.com/r/SwiftUI/comments/1xv3d72/; r/coolgithubprojects www.reddit.com/r/coolgithubprojects/comments/1xv6qu7/; r/MacOS www.reddit.com/r/MacOS/comments/1xw3d7w/; Rill www.reddit.com/r/unixporn/comments/1xrwi1k/
- Product Hunt: hunted.space/product/stablebar; our producthunt library post table (2026-11-11, score 85, daily_rank 18)
- GithubSignals: www.instagram.com/reel/DfrENqBj502/, and the matching FB video (3.9K views)
- Our github library (repo_profile / search, 2026-11-16): star counts for SketchyBar, simple-bar, barik, omacosy, zebar, Ice, Thaw and others
- Our hackernews library, x-radar and TikHub: all 0 entries