Stringers
alla2001/material-painter · alla2001

The third "open-source Substance Painter": borrowed .spp reading code, a line "Adobe is cooked," 118 stars in two days

What it is A free, open-source desktop app written in Rust for 3D model texture painting, modeled on Adobe Substance Painter. It can open Substance projects and ships with about 2,900 free materials built in.

Why it took off The "AI clones Adobe" trend was hot, and the author led with the material library, rain-streak rust and snow baking effects that look good at a glance, plus .spp import. Tool-recommendation account @dextune posted about it first, then game-scene account @Grummz reposted it with "Adobe is cooked" the same day. It gained 118 stars in two days.

CHow you could follow it Don't build another texture app. Pick a professional tool nobody has cloned yet, parse its file format using an open-source license others have already published, and spend your effort on built-in assets and effects you can explain in one sentence. Fix the top question from the first post's comments within two days, then send the screen recording to the tool-recommendation accounts on X.

C grade: it shows a latecomer can still get picked up by big accounts through packaging, but the result was a single burst of a little over two hundred stars, and that spot is already crowded with five projects. Copying it will get you even less. What's worth learning is the playbook, not this project. Chatter in the niche
Data (updated daily) · Repo created 2026-10-31 · 342 stars · 7 days +21
GitHub · stars
010020030011-0211-0611-1111-1611-20342
Data 2026-11-02 → 2026-11-20 (19 days, 19 observations). Points before 10-28 come from deeply / archive backfill, not every day has one

Material Painter is a Cologne tech artist's 3D texture painting app written with Claude. It's been in the repo 9 days and has 221 stars. It's not the first in this slot, and it doesn't have the most stars. Its key feature is code adapted from someone else's open source project. It got a 300K-follower game-dev account to post "Adobe is cooked" because of the packaging: it opens with 2,900 materials ready, a set of baking effects that artists understand at a glance, and a migration feature that users asked for and that was added in three and a half hours. Below: where the stars came from, why latecomers can still get a slice, and whether that slice is worth chasing.

three and a half hours

Around 2026 Nov 1, an account called u/Admirable-Struggle78 posted in r/3Dmodeling and r/IndieDev at the same time: "I built a free, open-source alternative to Substance Painter (Windows + Linux)," with a demo video. The first comment asked: "How does it compare to ArmorPaint? Can it read Substance Painter files?" The poster, who was the author, answered honestly: ArmorPaint is more mature, and Substance's .sbsar and .spp are proprietary formats that it can't read.

The next day, on Nov 2 19:55 (UTC), another open-source clone, SubCraft, released v0.2.0, the first version able to open .spp projects, under an MIT license. Three and a half hours later, 23:15, Material Painter submitted "Open Substance 3D Painter projects (.spp)." Its README ends by noting the Substance project reading code was adapted from SubCraft.

Five days later, Nov 7 15:16 (UTC), Mark Kern (former head of the World of Warcraft team, 304k followers on X) posted: "Adobe is cooked". The second sentence was "It imports your Substance files". By 11-09 the post had 67k views, 2,410 likes and 1,430 bookmarks (X, 11-09). Repo stars went from 96 on 11-07 to 214 on 11-09, +118 in two days, more than half the total.

What it is and who made it

A free, open-source desktop app (GPL-3.0, Rust + wgpu) with installers for Windows, Linux and macOS. The features follow Substance 3D Painter: layers, smart materials, masks, mesh baking, export presets for each engine (Unreal, Unity, Godot, Roblox, Blender), plus two things Substance Painter doesn't have: a material node graph, and a shader editor where you can write your own nodes in WGSL.

The author is Alla Eddine Rakik, a technical artist who graduated from the Cologne Game Lab in 2025. 26 followers on GitHub, 628 on LinkedIn, no real personal reach. The repo was created on 10-31, the first commit dropped 36k lines of code at once, so it was clearly built privately for a while. By 11-07 it had 41 commits, every one signed "Co-Authored-By: Claude", and 9 days later 6 releases. Under a Reddit post, someone wrote "you mean 'Claude did...'", and the author replied with a paragraph: most of the code was written by AI, but he decided what to build and tested and tuned it on his own machine, so he should say so in the post. It's GPL, every line is readable. If you want a tool made the traditional way, ArmorPaint, Material Maker and Ucupaint are all good.

Where the stars came from

TimelineWhat happenedStars (GitHub daily record)
10-31Created the repo, released v0.1.1—
About 11-01Author posts in r/3Dmodeling and r/IndieDev11-02 47 → 11-03 68
11-02/03Author posts a baking demo on LinkedIn, 17 likes11-04 75
11-04 to 11-06No new channels+3 to +5 per day
11-07 02:00 UTCTool-recommendation account @dextune (2,551 followers) posts: 21.5k views, 568 likes, 608 bookmarks11-07 96
11-07 15:16 UTC@Grummz posts "Adobe is cooked"11-08 157(+61)→ 11-09 214(+57)
laterThailand's Blenqube Facebook page, Korean Threads, and design aggregator sites repost the two posts above11-09 live 221,19 forks

The two X posts share one trait: bookmarks come close to or even exceed likes (@dextune 608 bookmarks to 568 likes). That's what a "tool post" looks like, people save it to use later. @dextune wrote a similar post about TextureCraft two days earlier, which only got 3,200 views. The same account's Material Painter post got nearly 7 times that. The difference was in the copy: it opens Substance projects, rain streaks and rust run down the model, wind and sand pile up in the corners, 2,900 free materials.

Not on the list: Hacker News, Product Hunt, standalone media coverage, YouTube reviews, ads. Whether @Grummz saw it through @dextune or elsewhere isn't visible from outside. The two posts were 13 hours apart, so the first one likely carried the second (inference).

Why the third entrant still got a slice

The topic is hot. Since October, the ArtCraft team has been using AI to rewrite Adobe's software as open-source Rust apps, and "AI clones Adobe" has become a talking point: 10-04 ArtCraft's Hacker News post got 180 points and 246 comments; 11-01 Engadget ran "AI Software Clones Are Coming For Big-Name Companies Like Adobe," and 11-05 Deutsche Welle ran "Goodbye, Adobe?" 10-11 Someone has already opened a proposal in ArtCraft's repo asking for a Substance Painter clone. @Grummz's "Adobe is cooked" line rides on this meme. He wants something he can point to and say it with, and whoever gets it in front of him first wins.

The hardest part was borrowed. "It can open the original app's project files" is the moment that convinces Substance users a switch is real, and reverse-engineering a proprietary format is the most time-consuming work. SubCraft was open-sourced under MIT, and Material Painter adopted it the same day, credited clearly. Latecomers don't have to go as deep as the first mover. They can stand on its code and spend their effort on packaging.

Packaging is done by people who know the field. Technical artists know what artists want to see: open the app and drag in a material from Poly Haven or ambientCG's 2,900 CC0 materials with one click; "environment baking" puts rain streaks, rust, wind erosion and snow on the model, which look great at a glance in screenshots and videos; the path tool draws seams along curves; export presets cover the major engines. These make up most of @dextune's copy, and tool accounts repost what can be explained in one line with a good-looking image.

When someone asks, build it right away. The first question in the Reddit comments was "can it read Substance files?" The author said no at the time. A day and a half later it could, and five days later it was the second line of the big-account post.

Who it's competing with

ProjectScale (GitHub, 11-09)Compared with Material Painter
Adobe Substance 3D PainterIndustry standard, subscription-basedThe thing being replaced
TextureCraft (from ArtCraft)546 starsAlso Rust and AI-written, backed by ArtCraft's brand and distribution, and runs in the browser
SubCraft377 starsStarted two and a half weeks earlier; it was first to read .spp files and also has a macOS build; picked up by a YouTube video with 100k views
ArmorPaint5,472 starsA veteran open-source alternative from 2017; the author admits it's more mature; the finished version is paid
Material Maker6,236 starsBuilt on Godot, leans toward procedural materials, painting is a side feature
Ucupaint2,320 starsA Blender add-on, doesn't run outside Blender

Three AI-written clones rose together that week, and this one ranked third. Its differences from the other two are the material library, environment baking and node graph; of the three, two share the same .spp reading code.

How many people behind the stars are actually using it

The installers across 6 releases have about 735 downloads in total (GitHub release page, 11-09), Windows at about 80%. The latest, v0.1.6, shipped about two hours after @Grummz's post and got 270 downloads in two days. The Discord server has 30 members, and there are only 1 issues.

Comparing with SubCraft makes it clearer: when SubCraft had 354 stars, it had about 3,700 cumulative downloads, 10 times its star count; Material Painter is over 3 times. A YouTube video gets people to watch the whole workflow before installing, while X tool posts mostly get bookmarks and stars. 67k views and 1,430 bookmarks ended up as a bit over a hundred stars and two or three hundred downloads. That is the conversion rate of one big-account post.

If it were you

Grade C: you can learn from it, but following it isn't worth it. It shows a latecomer who borrowed someone else's code and got the packaging right can still get picked up by a big account. But the result was two hundred-odd stars and one spike, and this spot is already crowded with five entrants. Building another texture app along the same lines would get even less.

Who it suits: someone who works in a specific professional field (3D, video, audio, CAD), knows what peers want to see the moment they open the software, can build features that are easy to explain in one sentence with a great screenshot; who uses tools like Claude Code to ship at high intensity; and who wants a project that gets seen once in their professional circle and goes on the résumé.

Who it doesn't suit: anyone building a sixth Substance Painter clone (TextureCraft, SubCraft and ArmorPaint are already ahead, and big accounts have already covered them); anyone who wants thousands of stars (the ceiling for this kind of project right now is a few hundred); anyone who doesn't know the field and just copies a feature list (Material Painter got reposted because people who know the field picked out the few effects that matter).

How to do it: copy three things it did, applied to a professional app that hasn't been cloned yet. First, check whether someone has already open-sourced a parser for the original app's file format under a permissive license. If so, use it, credit it, and spend your time on packaging. Second, bundle free assets in the first version so people can produce something nice the moment they open it. Third, after the launch post, watch the comments and ship a fix for the top question within two days, then put it in the first line of your next promo.

How to get users: first post in the relevant Reddit subreddits yourself, and use the questions in the comments as your to-do list. Then send a 30-second demo recording and a one-line pitch to tool-recommendation accounts on X (like @dextune: few followers, high bookmark rate). They're upstream of the big accounts. Don't expect to land a 300k-follower account, but when one scrolls past, your copy should already be the sentence they'd repost. If you want real users rather than just stars, prioritize YouTube channels willing to record long videos. SubCraft's download conversion was three times higher.

When to move: before the crowd, not on a calendar. When an "AI clones X" story hits Hacker News or tech media, you need a working build within two weeks. Once the topic cools, nobody will say "X is cooked" for you.

What would show you misjudged it: (1) a month from now, Material Painter has over a thousand stars, a Discord of several hundred, and the author is still releasing weekly. That would mean a latecomer can hold this spot through packaging, and it's less crowded than it looks. (2) The reverse: if by December it has stalled below 300 stars and commits have stopped, this slice only fed once, and even "learning from it" has to be discounted. (3) If Adobe takes it down after a trademark or format complaint, the "open the original project" trick carries legal risk against big companies, and you need to think that through before building the next one.

Data and sources

  • Repo: github.com/alla2001/material-painter (README, commit history, release-page download counts, Discord invite page member count, 11-09); daily star counts recorded from 11-02 to 11-09.
  • Reddit launch post: r/3Dmodeling "I built a free, open-source alternative to Substance Painter (Windows + Linux)" and comments as written, plus a same-titled post on r/IndieDev; vote counts not retrieved.
  • X: @Grummz post 11-07 (x.com/Grummz/status/2119086676194861233), @dextune post 11-07 (x.com/dextune/status/2118886157253742851), @dextune's TextureCraft post 11-05; view, like and bookmark counts taken from 11-09.
  • SubCraft: github.com/Aalzard/subcraft release page (v0.2.0 released 11-02 19:55 UTC, includes a macOS build), download count (11-06).
  • Competitor star counts: GitHub pages for TextureCraft, SubCraft, ArmorPaint, Material Maker and Ucupaint (11-09).
  • Coverage: Hacker News ArtCraft post (10-04); Engadget 11-01; DW 11-05; storytold/craft-launcher issue #183 (10-11).
  • Author background: allarakik.com, public LinkedIn profile.
  • "@Grummz saw it through @dextune" is an inference.

GitHub repo ↗

Research notes: competitor table, acquisition evidence, full research report
Competitors
NameWhereLaunchedScaleHow it differs from this one
Adobe Substance 3D PainterBig-company features2014 (acquired by Adobe in 2019)Industry standard, subscription model, also a one-time Steam purchaseThe thing being replaced; Material Painter is free and can open its .spp projects
ArmorPaint (armory3d/armorpaint)Open source2017-025,472 stars, gaining 2–7 per dayMore mature, but can't read .spp, and the finished version is paid; Material Painter adds a material node graph, custom WGSL nodes, custom environment baking, and 2,900 materials
Material Maker (RodZill4)Open source2018-076,236 starsBuilt on Godot, leans toward Substance Designer-style procedural materials, painting is a side feature
UcupaintOpen source2022-032,320 stars, 11-01 posts 3.0A Blender add-on; Material Painter is a standalone app
TextureCraft (storytold/texturecraft,ArtCraft)Open sourceRepo created 2026-10-14, 10-24 v0.1.0544 stars, 173 forksSame topic and same timing, also pure Rust + AI-written, backed by ArtCraft's distribution (39.9K stars), and runs in the browser; no .spp import and no large material library
SubCraft (Aalzard/subcraft)Open source2026-10-13375 stars, 11-04 daily +207A Rust app in the same category, Windows/Linux only; Material Painter's .spp reading code was adapted from it
Mixos / Trumble.appWebNot verifiedSmallA Substance-style editor in the browser; Material Painter is a native desktop app
Where users come from
  • Verified Author's own Reddit posts (r/3Dmodeling, r/IndieDev): around 11-01 u/Admirable-Struggle78 posted "I built a free, open-source alternative to Substance Painter" with a demo video, and the author answered questions in the comments; the repo shows 11-03 +21 stars
  • Verified Author's LinkedIn post: about 11-02/03 demonstrating rain streak and wind erosion baking, 17 likes, the author has 628 followers
  • Verified X tool-recommendation account @dextune: 11-07 02:00 UTC, 2,549 followers, 21.5K views, 567 likes, 607 bookmarks; pitched as opening .spp, custom baking, 2,900 materials
  • Verified X big account @Grummz (Mark Kern, 304k followers): 11-07 15:16 UTC, "Adobe is cooked…It imports your Substance files", 67K views, 2,407 likes, 1,428 bookmarks; matching repo gain 11-08 +61, 11-09 +57 stars
  • Verified Reposts (Thai Blenqube FB, Korean Threads, Design Radar aggregator): Jina/Exa search results pick up these posts
  • Verified Platform moment: the "AI clones Adobe" buzz sparked by ArtCraft: HN ArtCraft post 10-04 180 points; covered by Engadget 11-01 and DW 11-05; craft-launcher issue #183 has users asking for a Substance Painter replacement
  • Inferred Retweets by industry figures like @MeshModeler: mentioned in the data card; original post not found
  • Inferred HN / Product Hunt / press / YouTube / ads: none found in the hackernews library or search

alla2001/material-painter: free, open-source Substance Painter alternative (Rust + wgpu)

Research date 2026-11-08/09 (library data through 11-09). Repo github.com/alla2001/material-painter, GPL-3.0, author Alla Eddine Rakik (a technical artist in Cologne, graduated Cologne Game Lab in 2025, allarakik.com/).

Bottom line

Material Painter is a Substance 3D Painter clone that a technical artist wrote almost from scratch with Claude Opus 5.5. Its rise came mainly from timing: October ArtCraft used AI to rewrite the Adobe suite in a "clean room," sparking a wave of "AI clones Adobe" coverage (HN 180 points, Engadget and DW both reported on it), and it rode that wave. On distribution, it first cold-started with its own Reddit post and gained few stars; 11-07 a tools-recommendation account @dextune wrote about it, and that same day the game-industry figure @Grummz (Mark Kern, 300k followers) posted "Adobe is cooked", bringing in 118 stars over two days, more than half its total. On the product side, it can open Substance .spp project files, includes about 2,900 built-in CC0 materials, and has ready installers for Windows, Linux and macOS, which makes the pitch "replace your Adobe subscription for free" credible. Its differentiator (.spp import) was the first selling point in Grummz's post, but it isn't the only one in its category: ArtCraft's own TextureCraft got 544 stars, and SubCraft has 375. It's the category taking off as a whole, not it alone dominating.

1. Data

  • GitHub stars (our repo_day snapshots, Beijing time): 11-02 47 → 11-03 68 (+21) → 11-04 75 → 11-05 78 → 11-06 83 → 11-07 96 (+13) → 11-08 157 (+61) → 11-09 214 (+57); forks 4 → 19. Checked live via the gh API just now: 221 stars, 19 forks, 3 watchers. 11-09
  • Repo created: 2026-10-31 23:03 UTC; the first commit, "Initial import", landed 36,663 lines at once (mostly Rust, plus 214KB of WGSL shaders), suggesting weeks of private work beforehand. Through 11-07 there are 41 commits in total, each carrying Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5. The repo includes an AGENTS.md for AI coding agents, and CONTRIBUTING explicitly welcomes AI-assisted contributions. The author is the only contributor.
  • Releases: 9 days, 6 versions shipped (v0.1.1 10-31 → v0.1.6 11-07). Installer downloads across all releases total about 734 times (GitHub releases API): Windows about 593, Linux 90, macOS 51. v0.1.6 got 269 downloads in its first two days. Treat this as a ceiling on real usage; stars and downloads run at roughly 1:3.
  • Community: Discord 30 members (9 online, via invite API); only 1 issues (11-06 filed by user BR1-gg); the Ko-fi tipping page doesn't show supporter counts.
  • The author has 46 public GitHub repos and 26 followers; 628 LinkedIn followers. No real personal audience base.

2. Competitors

NameWhereLaunchedScaleHow Material Painter differs
Adobe Substance 3D PainterBig-company software2014 years (Allegorithmic, acquired by Adobe in 2019)The industry standard; subscription-based, with a one-time-purchase version on Steam since 2026-10 (per a fsdeveloper forum thread)The incumbent being replaced; Material Painter's pitch is "free + opens your .spp"
ArmorPaint(armory3d/armorpaint)Open source2017-025,472 stars, 654 forks; gaining 2–7 stars a day over the past two weeksMore mature: source is free, finished builds are paid (about $20); the author admitted on Reddit that "ArmorPaint is more mature". Material Painter offers more: a material node graph, custom WGSL nodes, GPU baking cache, .spp import
Material Maker(RodZill4)Open source2018-076,236 stars; 11-06 shipped 1.8Built on Godot, leans toward Substance Designer (procedural materials), with painting as a side feature
UcupaintOpen-source Blender add-on2022-032,320 stars; 11-01 shipped 3.0, covered by DIGITAL PRODUCTIONLives inside Blender; Material Painter is a standalone program
TextureCraft (storytold/texturecraft, from ArtCraft)Open sourceRepo created 2026-10-14, 10-24 v0.1.0544 stars, 173 forks; 11-04 gained +113 in a single day; covered by MODELING HAPPY and inithtml, and @dextune wrote about it (3.2K views) 11-05Same niche and timing, also pure Rust + AI-written, backed by ArtCraft's distribution (main repo 39.9K stars, craft-launcher 5.1K stars); it also runs in the browser (WASM). Material Painter is an independent author, with .spp import, 2,900 materials and custom baking on top
SubCraft(Aalzard/subcraft)Open sourceRepo created 2026-10-13, 10-14 v0.1.0375 stars; 11-04 gained +207 in a single dayA Rust app in the same niche, but Windows/Linux only. Material Painter's .spp reading code was adapted from SubCraft (MIT), as its README states
Mixos / Trumble.appWebNot verifiedSmallA free Substance-style editor that runs in the browser; Material Painter is a native desktop app
Quixel Mixer, 3DCoat, Mari, InstaMATOtherAlready live—Mixer is free but no longer updated (unverified); the rest are paid or free for non-commercial use only

Also, user 10-11 opened issue #183 on ArtCraft's craft-launcher, "PainterCraft: open-source Substance 3D Painter alternative in Rust", with 18 comments and a string of +1 reactions. So an open-source Substance alternative was already being explicitly requested three weeks before Material Painter launched.

3. Where users came from (by time)

  1. Author's own Reddit launch (confirmed). Around 11-01, u/Admirable-Struggle78 (the author, answering questions as the developer in the comments) posted "I built a free, open-source alternative to Substance Painter (Windows + Linux)" with a demo video in r/3Dmodeling (tagged "Free Assets & Tools") and r/IndieDev. The first comment asked, "How does it compare to ArmorPaint? Can it read Substance assets?" The author replied that .sbsar/.spp are proprietary and unreadable at the time, and the next day (11-02 23:15 UTC) committed "Open Substance 3D Painter projects (.spp)". The post is now locked and its upvotes weren't captured (Reddit blocked scraping). The matching repo gain was +11-03 21 stars.
  2. Author's LinkedIn post (confirmed). Posted around 11-02/03, showing newly added rain-streak and wind-erosion baking, with 17 likes. Small impact.
  3. @dextune tool-recommendation post (confirmed). Posted 11-07 02:00 UTC by an account with 2,549 followers, 21.5K views, 567 likes, 607 bookmarks (fxtwitter). The copy leads with "opens Substance 3D Painter projects", custom baking (rain streaks, rust, wind-blown sand and snow), and 2,900 CC0 materials. The account also wrote about TextureCraft two days earlier, which got only 3.2K views.
  4. Retweet from big account @Grummz (confirmed, the main spike). Posted 11-07 15:16 UTC by Mark Kern (former World of Warcraft team lead, gaming commentator, 304k followers): "Adobe is cooked. Someone just released a Substance Painter clone called Material Painter. It imports your Substance files… I compiled and ran it and ...well it's pretty impressive". 67K views, 2,407 likes, 1,428 bookmarks, 219 reposts. This matches the repo gains of 11-08 +61 and 11-09 +57. The replies split into "Adobe deserves it" and "clearly AI-written" camps, and someone recommended Ucupaint.
  5. Reposts (confirmed, small volume). Thailand's Blenqube Facebook page, Korean Threads user @dhdbtkd ("get the texture quality with about 2,900 free materials first"), and aggregators like Design Radar all picked up the dextune and Grummz posts.
  6. Not found: HN (neither our hackernews library nor search has a post for it), Product Hunt, press coverage, YouTube reviews, ads. The @MeshModeler retweet mentioned in the data card (PlayStation lead material artist Javier Perez) was not found in original form and is unverified.

4. Why it took off

  • Timing: the AI-clones-Adobe debate was hot. On HN, "ArtCraft Apps – open-source Adobe compatible suite written in Rust" got 180 points and 246 comments (10-04); another post hit 91 points (10-25); Engadget ran "AI Software Clones Are Coming For Big-Name Companies Like Adobe" (11-01), and DW ran "Goodbye, Adobe? AI Is Making Software Free" (11-05). Grummz's "Adobe is cooked" line rides directly on this meme. Substance Painter was a gap ArtCraft hadn't filled yet (users named it in issue #183), and Material Painter filled it.
  • The need is real: students, indie devs, and hobbyists have been asking "Substance is too expensive, what's free?" for years (old threads on Reddit and BlenderArtists). The answers were ArmorPaint, Material Maker, and Blender add-ons, none of which match the Substance workflow.
  • .spp import is a strong hook: two days after launch, a user asked "can it read Substance?" and the author shipped it the next day (code adapted from SubCraft). Grummz's post said "It imports your Substance files" in the second sentence. For Substance users, switching cost is the biggest worry, and this addresses it directly.
  • Downloads just work: prebuilt installers for all three platforms, with about 2,900 CC0 materials from Poly Haven and ambientCG built in. You can open it and get good-looking results right away, and the screenshots and videos look great. That matters for saves on X: both posts had saves close to or above half their likes.
  • The author knows the domain, and AI supplied the volume: the author is a technical artist who writes shaders and knows what artists need (custom baked rain streaks and erosion, a seam path tool, export presets covering Unreal/Unity/Godot/Roblox). Feature volume came from Claude: 9 days, 41 commits, 6 releases.

5. Differentiation, and whether it's the reason it took off

Compared with established open-source alternatives, its differentiation is .spp project import + a Substance-style UI + a large built-in material library + node graph / user-written WGSL nodes + custom environment baking. It's the one that is "most like Substance and easiest to move over from Substance." Compared with contemporary AI-written Rust clones (TextureCraft, SubCraft), the gap is smaller: they're all Rust with Substance-style layouts. Material Painter wins on .spp import, the material library, and having a macOS build, and loses on distribution the way ArtCraft has it.

Is that why it took off? Partly. .spp import and the "familiar UI" let big accounts write it up with "Adobe is cooked," which is differentiation at work. But most of its stars came from one big-account repost, and TextureCraft (544) and SubCraft (375) rose in the same week, so the more accurate read is: the "AI clones Adobe" topic got hot, and this is the best-packaged option in the Substance Painter slot.

6. How many people saw it

It spread within a small circle. One post from a 300k-follower big account (67K views) and one from a 2.5K-follower tool-recommendation account (21K views), plus a Reddit launch. No media coverage on its own, not on HN, and only 221 stars. It's open source and free, so there's no revenue to speak of (only Ko-fi tips, with no visible totals). Copycats: I didn't see anyone copying it. TextureCraft and SubCraft were built in parallel at the same time, so they count as parallel competitors, not copycats.

7. What to borrow

  • The "AI clean-room rewrite of X" playbook can be repeated: pick professional software that users resent for its subscription model and that has a mature open-source alternative that doesn't feel "close enough," then use AI to quickly build a version with nearly identical UI and workflow. The key is reading the original software's project files (here, .spp). That's the moment that convinces people they can actually switch.
  • Ride a hot narrative: at launch, tie into the "AI clones Adobe" topic that was trending, and big accounts will sum it up for you in one line ("Adobe is cooked").
  • Use the launch-post comments as a demand pool: when users asked "can it read Substance?", the author built it the next day and then made it the first selling point.
  • Good-looking results on open: a built-in CC0 material library plus HDRIs. Screenshots and videos naturally get saved on X.
  • Borrow other open-source code for key capabilities: .spp reading was adapted directly from the MIT-licensed SubCraft, which saved the time of reverse-engineering the file format.

8. Still unclear

  • Vote counts and view counts on the Reddit launch posts (scraping was blocked). Whether Grummz found it via dextune or somewhere else.
  • Whether industry figures like MeshModeler reposted it (no original posts found).
  • Real retention: 734 downloads and 30 Discord members, a very small base. How long the author can maintain it (a side project, and the maintainability of AI-generated code was questioned in X replies).
  • Whether Adobe sends a letter over trademarks or the .spp format (the README already states no affiliation with Adobe; Engadget mentioned Adobe's terms prohibit reverse engineering).
  • How long the growth can last: right now it's a single pulse from big accounts, 11-09 has dropped from 61 to 57, and there's no data after that yet.

Sources

This article was written by AI from public data and the data we collect daily. Numbers are sourced, and inferences are labeled.