
Built 31 minutes earlier than a 25k-star winner, yet only 525 stars: why a DSH plugin directory lost
What it is A DeepSeek Harness plugin directory. Every day it scrapes GitHub repos tagged dsh-plugin, verifies them in batches with AI, and lists the ones that pass. You can also subscribe to it directly from dsh's Discover page.
Why it got attention By stars it didn't break out. Nearly half its stars came from the bump in dsh's first open-source week; the rest came from plugin authors submitting PRs. What it actually earned was a spot among a dozen-plus subscription sources after dsh opened third-party feeds, by "only listing real plugins, and star-inflated ones stay out."
CHow you could follow this Don't build another dsh directory. Save this playbook for the day the next agent ecosystem opens plugins: launch the same day as the open-source release, lower the bar for listing, ship a human-facing directory and a machine-readable feed together, and get your influence or a client that bundles your data ready first.
- Data (updated daily) · repo created 2026-08-13 · 521 stars
GitHub · stars Data 2026-10-09 → 2026-11-16 (39 days, 39 observations). Points before 10-28 come from deeply / archive backfill, not every day has one
Aug 13, 2026: an hour and a half after DeepSeek Harness open-sourced, Bruce Van created a plugin directory called awesome-dsh-plugin. 31 minutes later, someone else created one with the same name. Three months on, the latter has 25k stars and the former has 525. He shipped first, grabbed the name, and maintained it daily, and he still lost. Below: where he went wrong, what he found beyond stars, and what you need ready to claim that spot when the next Agent ecosystem opens its plugins.
A post with 115 views
On the morning of Nov 11, Bruce Van posted on X:
Hadn't checked PRs in two days, and found Tw93 had submitted a PR to my project and I merged it right away! … Let me also plug the awesome-dsh-plugin curated repo I maintain. 3 months of careful upkeep, 600+ commits, 50+ contributors, with illustrations. Thanks for the support.
Tw93 is the author of Mole, a Mac cleanup tool well known in Chinese developer circles. He submitted a PR that got his dsh-mole plugin listed in the directory. The self-promo post has 115 views so far, and the repo gained 8 stars that day (Trendshift daily data).
This directory was not short on effort. The gaps it had are covered one by one below.
What it is
A plugin directory for DeepSeek Harness (dsh for short). When dsh went open source, the official only said "tag your repo dsh-plugin". There was no official marketplace. So this directory scrapes every GitHub repo with that tag each day and checks each README for a real dsh install method. Real plugins get categorized and listed. Repos that just piggyback on the tag get removed, with the reason published. As of 11-17, it has verified 28,724 repos in total.
Besides the README for people, it ships two things for programs: an npm package (21,137 downloads over the last 30 days, per npm's official stats) and a subscription URL you can paste straight into dsh's Discover page.
The author, Bruce Van, is an individual developer with 73 GitHub followers. He previously built an Agent Skills security scanner with 393 stars. Three months and 745 commits in, he publishes a daily audit log that says "341 entries fetched in parallel batches, metadata and README per repo." One person maintaining nearly thirty thousand directory entries, with most of the work done by AI agents in batches. 11-17 The repo was renamed awesome-dsh-plugin-pro, and the old address redirects automatically.
Half an hour early, and still lost
| Time (UTC) | What happened |
|---|---|
| 08-13 11:56 | deepseek-ai/deepseek-harness repo created, now 283k stars |
| 08-13 13:24 | Bruce Van's awesome-dsh-plugin repo created, first bilingual Chinese/English directory pushed 13:29 later |
| 08-13 13:55 | fkysly (Ma Tianyi)'s awesome-dsh-plugin repo created |
| 08-19 | An official discussion thread, "a week of observations on community plugin markets," counted 82 directory and market projects. Variants of the name awesome-dsh-plugin alone numbered 29. Among directories, fkysly's, with 9,646 stars, ranks #1; this one, with 242 stars, ranks #5. |
| 11-18 | fkysly's: 25,016 stars; this one: 525 stars |
In other words, in the first 6 days this directory got close to half the total, and after that came a long tail of 0 to 8 stars a day, peaking at +9 (10-21). Those 242 stars were dsh's first-week bump, and anyone in the room could take a slice.
The gap was two orders of magnitude. Four reasons explain it, and each one matters more than launching half an hour early:
- Whether anyone was watching the author. fkysly has 15.7k followers on X, and big accounts relayed the directory the day it launched. Bruce Van's post had a little over a hundred views.
- The listing bar. fkysly's directory took a YAML from any plugin author and listed it, without checking installs. Thousands of authors were willing to submit, and they starred it while they were there. This one verifies, so it's stricter and fewer people bothered. In August it also got 106 PRs from 78 accounts, but the scale was far smaller.
- Whether a major client bundled it. fkysly's companion marketplace plugin is built into a desktop client with 35k stars. Bruce Van's own client, dsh-desktop-pro, has 98 stars.
- The name collided. Search for "awesome-dsh-plugin" and the other one comes up first.
Where the 525 stars came from
| Channel | What's going on | Volume |
|---|---|---|
| dsh's first open-source week | Official repo live within 1.5 hours | First 6 days: 242 stars, nearly half |
| Plugin authors submitting PRs and self-promoting | Has dedicated "recommend a plugin" and "author self-promo" entries; 141 PRs total, 106 of them in August | Single digits per day, can't be broken down further |
| Traffic from its own product | The README's first featured entry promotes the author's own desktop client, which subscribes to this directory by default | Small |
| Auto-listed by aggregator sites | Because it carries the dsh-plugin tag itself, a dozen-plus plugin aggregators picked it up automatically | Long tail, volume unknown |
| Author's X post | Entries 10-17 and 11-11 | 11-11 that day +8 |
No sign of star-buying; the curve is flat. English media and several "must-install dsh plugins" roundups don't mention it. They all point to fkysly's.
Beyond stars: it held ground in a new entry point
The interesting part of this directory isn't the stars.
In October, dsh 0.2.1 added a feature: the Discover page can now add third-party plugin index sources. Enter a URL and you can browse and install plugins other people have curated, right inside dsh. The official only provided the mechanism and brought no curation of its own. Bruce Van quickly turned his directory into a subscription source in the right format, named "Bruce's Curated Plugins," and listed 1,673 installable plugins sorted by stars.
His site self-reports 15,832 unique IPs and 47,459 fetches. Discount that number: the start date for counting isn't public. Also, from 11-15 his own client v0.6.0 subscribes to this URL by default on first launch, so part of the volume is built in, and there's no way to tell how much.
In this new entry point, its strictness became the selling point. A Zhihu roundup of subscription sources (10-25 editor, 6 upvotes) listed about 14 sources, all side by side in the same dropdown. Others compete on count (dsh.so has 9,726 entries, realoiyo has 7,490), while this one says "only real plugins, piggybackers removed, star-inflated ones kept off the list." It really does do the star-inflation part: on 11-18 it moved a suspicious project off the ranking and kept it only in the directory.
So there are two ways to read it. By stars, it didn't break out. By "does anyone subscribe to it inside dsh," it holds a spot, but how big that spot is can't be pinned down.
Who is competing for the same spot
- fkysly's awesome-dsh-plugin: 25k stars, still gaining 7 over the last 810 days; the de facto standard directory.
- dsh-market: 12,761 stars; its npm package gets 30M downloads over the last 1.28 days and is bundled in several clients. Bruce Van's counterpart, dsh-market-pro, has 9 stars.
- AdamPlatin123's dsh-plugin-radar: 1,507 stars. It runs each plugin in a container to check it actually installs and works, which is harder verification than reading READMEs.
- A run of same-named lists: 570, 434, 380, 194 stars, most of which have stopped growing.
- The dsh official: If the official ever ships its own curated list, every third-party subscription source gets pushed aside. That's the biggest risk for this kind of project.
If it were you
In short: don't build another dsh plugin directory. That spot was taken three months ago. What's worth learning is the playbook, to use the day the next ecosystem opens plugins.
Who it's for: Developers who already have a few thousand followers on X or Jike and can sit at the keyboard the day the new ecosystem open-sources; or teams with a sizable client that can preload the directory by default.
Who it's not for: Individuals with no reach and no distribution channel. Bruce Van has shown that getting there half an hour early, maintaining diligently and being strict gets you at most 2% of the winner's stars.
How to do it:
- Watch for agent products that just open-sourced, extend via plugins or skills, but have no official marketplace yet. Be listed on the day they open-source, not the next day.
- Lower the bar for inclusion. Let plugin authors get listed with a single file; the more authors, the more stars and spread. Do review, but do it at the featured and ranking layer, not at the entry gate.
- Ship three forms at once: a README for humans, JSON or an npm package for programs, and a subscription format the host may support later. The moment the host opens subscriptions, you're first in its discovery page.
- Let agents run the review in batches and keep a public record every day. One person can maintain tens of thousands of entries; Bruce Van has already proven this.
How to get users: Post on X the day it opens source, @-tagging the host's official accounts and big names in the ecosystem; get one or two well-known plugin authors listed first and have them repost; aim to have the top client bundle your data source. That last one matters more than everything else combined.
When it's worth it: It only pays off in the first few days after an ecosystem open-sources. In this dsh round, by the end of week one, 29 same-named directories had already been ranked.
Signs you're reading it wrong: If in the next ecosystem the official project ships its own plugin marketplace on open-source day, third-party directories have no gap; don't rush in. If you're still not top three in your category three days after launch, distribution is too weak: stop early, don't maintain it for three months like this one did.
Research notes: competitor table, acquisition evidence, full research report
- Competitors
Name Where Launched Scale How it differs from this one awesome-dsh-plugin/awesome-dsh-plugin(fkysly) Open source 2026-08-13 25,012 stars, +7 in the last 810 days; site awesome-dsh-plugin.com Listed on submitting a YAML, no install verification; the author has 15.7k followers on X; the companion dsh-market is bundled by the top client. This list has stricter inclusion and an audit trail, but reach and fame are two orders of magnitude apart. dsh-market/dsh-market + dshmarket.com index Open source 2026-08-14 12,761 stars; npm dshmarket 30M downloads in the last 1.28 days Marketplace plugin bundled in the client; the corresponding dsh-market-pro here has only 9 stars AdamPlatin123/awesome-dsh-plugins / dsh-plugin-radar Open source 2026-08 08-19 at 1,238 stars; radar currently 1,507 Actually install everything in a container to check it runs; verification is firmer than this list's reading of READMEs. 0xsline/awesome-deepseek-harness Open source 2026-08-11 1,381 star Ecosystem overview list, no subscription feed Zhiyuan-Fan / Dominic789654 / libukai / beancookie and other awesome variants Open source 2026-08-13 570 / 434 / 380 / 194 star Homogeneous lists, mostly stopped growing, no verification and no subscription feed imsai-sh, dshplugin/dsh-plugin-hub, dshfind and other SEO directory sites Web 2026-08-13~20 401 / 539 / 400 star Competing on listing volume (10k–20k entries), no manual verification Other subscription feeds: dsh.so, realoiyo, dsh.works, polang233, easonmws, etc. Other From ¥2026-10 dsh.so 9,726 entries, realoiyo 7,490 entries (Zhihu roundup, 10-25) Sits side by side in the same dropdown on the Discover page; this list has a medium entry count, and its selling point is that it only lists real plugins, cuts off by a star threshold, and keeps star-farmed projects off the rankings. DSH official Discover page + plugin_market tool Big-company features dsh 0.2.1(2026-10) Shipped with official distribution The official side only provides the subscription mechanism, not a curated directory; third-party feeds fill exactly this gap. If the official side builds its own curated list one day, this list will be threatened. - Where users come from
- Verified Platform-event head start: the official repo was created 08-13 11:56 UTC, this one 13:24 (31 minutes earlier than the fkysly version); in the first 6 days it reached 242 stars, about 46% of the total
- Verified Plugin authors submit PRs / self-nominate: 141 PRs (August has 106), from 78 external accounts; 56 contributors; there's a SHOWCASE self-nomination entry
- Verified Cross-promotion from the author's own product line: the top featured recommendation in the README promotes the author's own DSH Desktop Pro; dsh-desktop-pro v0.6.0(11-15) auto-subscribes on first launch to bruc3van.com/dsh-plugins/index.json; previously safer-dsh-market read awesome-dsh-plugin-feed
- Verified Roundup article on subscription feeds: the Zhihu post by HackPoet, 'Sharing custom plugin marketplace index sources for deepseek Harness' (10-25 editors, 6 upvotes), lists 'Bruce's curated plugins'; there are reposts on CSDN
- Verified Author's X posts: 10-17 posts cover custom plugin marketplaces; 11-11 self-nominates via a PR tagging Tw93, 115 views, Trendshift shows +8 that day
- Verified Auto-indexed by aggregator sites: deepseek-code.com, dshbazaar.io, dshplugin.sh, plugin.dshx.dev, dsh-pluginmarket/metadata and others auto-index it because of the dsh-plugin tag
- Inferred Media / big accounts / paid acquisition: it doesn't appear in composio, atlascloud, Zhihu roundups or Tencent Cloud articles; 0 entries in x-radar; the curve is smooth with no sign of star farming
Why bruc3van/awesome-dsh-plugin (now renamed awesome-dsh-plugin-pro) got this far
Research date 2026-11-18 (the brief's 'today' is 11-07, the data card refreshed to 11-18). Data card: 2026-08-13,521 stars at creation, 77 forks, +7 in the last 17 days, 0 trending appearances. GitHub API that day: 525 stars, 80 forks; the repo was renamed to bruc3van/awesome-dsh-plugin-pro (11-17), and the old address redirects automatically.
One line
To be clear: by stars, it has not broken out. It's a second-tier 'awesome' directory in the DeepSeek Harness (dsh) plugin ecosystem: it was created 31 minutes earlier than the winner awesome-dsh-plugin/awesome-dsh-plugin (Ma Tianyi @fkysly, 25,012 stars), yet has only 2% of its stars. Of these 525 stars, about half came from the platform bonus in dsh's first week open-source (8/19 already at 242); the rest came from plugin authors submitting PRs to get listed and the author's products cross-promoting each other, gaining 2–8 a day.
The part really worth watching is the route beyond stars: after dsh 0.2.1 opened 'custom plugin marketplaces / index sources', the author turned this directory into a subscribable index source (bruc3van.com/dsh-plugins/index.json), and his own desktop client dsh-desktop-pro subscribes to it by default on first launch. The site self-reports 15,832 unique IPs and 47,459 directory fetches. The differentiator is 'human (in practice, agents in batches) checking each entry one by one, tag-stuffed repos removed, star-farmed ones kept off the rankings'. That difference lets it hold a spot among a dozen-plus subscription feeds, but it is not why it got its stars.
1. What it is
- A DeepSeek Harness plugin directory: each day it crawls GitHub repos tagged
dsh-plugin(as of 11-17, 28,724 verified repos in total,data/stats.json), reviews each one and then sorts it into categories. Extras include scenario-based 'featured picks' (with screenshots), Star Top 50/200, 'author self-nominations' (SHOWCASE), and beginner bundles. Tag-stuffed repos go on theexcluded_reposblacklist with public removal reasons; daily review logs are kept indata/review/YYYY-MM-DD.md(42 so far). - There are three machine-readable data sets:
data/repositories.json(27 MB snapshot),data/market-v2.json(for downstream marketplaces, ≤1000 entries), and the npm data packageawesome-dsh-plugin-feed(since 2026-09-26, 136 versions, 21,137 downloads in the last 30 days, api.npmjs.org). - Subscription feed:
https://bruc3van.com/dsh-plugins/index.json, in the third-party index format of dsh's official Discover page. Its display name is 'Bruce's curated plugins'; it includes 1,673 plugins that install directly (shown on the site as 11-18), cut off by star count from highest to lowest within a 5 MiB gateway size budget. - The same author's product line, all pulling data from or cross-promoting this directory:
dsh-market-pro(formerly safer-dsh-market): a marketplace plugin installed inside dsh, selling 'AI security review after install'. The old npm package safer-dsh-market has about 4,758 cumulative downloads; the new package 11-17 was only just published.dsh-desktop-pro(formerly dsh-desktop): a desktop client with 98 stars, focused on the enterprise edition (centrally distributed models, plugins and permissions). Installers across 24 releases have 17,782 cumulative downloads (GitHub releases API). From v0.6.0(11-15) on, first launch automatically opens 'custom plugin marketplace' and subscribes to the address above (CHANGELOG).
- Author Bruce Van (@bruc3van): 73 GitHub followers. His older project agent-skills-guard (a desktop app for security scanning of Agent Skills) has 393 stars. His X bio reads 'trained models, took part in AI safety standards', and the account has 1,185 posts. His self-nomination post 11-11 got only 115 views, showing his influence on X is very small.
- Operations are clearly run by AI agents: 745 commits, most with long machine-style descriptions; 11-18's review log says '341 repos fetched in parallel batches, pulling GitHub metadata and READMEs'. One person maintaining 28k entries is only possible because of agent batch review.
2. Timing: grabbing a spot the day dsh open-sourced
- deepseek-ai/deepseek-harness was created 2026-08-13 11:56 UTC and now has 283k stars (our GitHub repo, 11-18). The slogan is 'Everything is a Plugin'; the official side only asks people to tag repos
dsh-plugin, with no official marketplace. - This repo was created 08-13 13:24 UTC, with the first Chinese-English directory version pushed 13:29; fkysly's awesome-dsh-plugin was created 13:55 (GitHub API created_at). In other words, this repo is one of the earliest awesome directories in the ecosystem, half an hour ahead of the later winner.
- Official discussion #3395, "Weekly Observations on the Community Plugin Marketplace" (08-19), counted 82 marketplace / directory projects. Among directory projects, this database ranks #5: 242 stars, 128 commits, 24 contributors, noted as "daily scraping + manual verification + public blocklist." #1 fkysly had 9,646 stars at the time. The same post also mentions 29 repos with variants of the name awesome-dsh-plugin.
Star curve (stitched together):
- 08-19:242(Discussion #3395)
- About 09-19: about 344 (Trendshift shows 09-19 to 11-18 totaling +181, back-calculated)
- 10-27:471; 11-16:521 (our GitHub repo_day)
Single-day peak +9 (10-21). In other words, the first 6 days got about 46% of the total, after which it gained 0–8 a day, a long tail ever since.
3. Where users came from (growth tactics)
| Channel | Evidence | Confirmed? |
|---|---|---|
| Platform event + getting there first | About 1.5 hours after the official repo was created, this one was up; first 6 days to 242 stars | Confirmed |
| Plugin authors submitting PRs for inclusion / self-nominating | Total 141 PRs (77 merged), 106 of them in August alone, from 78 different PR accounts; 56 contributors in all. It has a dedicated "recommend a plugin" and SHOWCASE "self-nomination" entry, so authors submit PRs to get listed (and will probably star it too). The author 11-11 posted on X: "maintained with care for 3 months, 600+ commits in total, 50+ people involved" | confirmed (how many stars it brought is unverified) |
| cross-promotion between the author's own products | The first item under the README's "featured picks" promotes the author's own DSH Desktop Pro; the website and the project page link to each other; dsh-desktop-pro v0.6.0 automatically subscribes to this directory's index on first launch; the previously bundled safer-dsh-market read awesome-dsh-plugin-feed | Confirmed |
| subscription feeds shared in articles | A Zhihu article, "DeepSeek Harness custom plugin market index sources" (HackPoet, 10-25 editor picks, 6 upvotes), lists about 14 sources, and "Bruce's curated plugins" is one of them (1,000 entries at the time); CSDN has reposts | Confirmed (very small volume) |
| Author's X post | 10-17 posted that the new dsh version supports custom plugin markets and can connect to various Awesome lists; 11-11 self-promoted by giving this repo's PR opportunity to Tw93 (Mole's author, a big V), 115 views. Trendshift showed 11-11 +8 that day | Confirmed (very small effect) |
| Auto-listed by aggregator sites | Because this repo also carries the dsh-plugin topic, more than a dozen sites auto-indexed it: deepseek-code.com, dshbazaar.io, dshplugin.sh, plugin.dshx.dev, yhbd.top, wxtko.com, dsh-pluginmarket/metadata (which auto-submitted "Add: bruc3van/awesome-dsh-plugin" 3 times in total), and others | confirmed (long tail, volume unknown) |
| downstream third-party integrations | ALL-PAY-C/HarnessForAndroid (1 stars, not yet usable) hardcodes bruc3van/awesome-dsh-plugin/main/data/market-v2.json as its default plugin source; brickhu's research doc lists awesome-dsh-plugin-feed (10-30 at the time, 12,632 downloads per month) as one of the community market packages | Confirmed (very small scale) |
| Media / big accounts | bruc10van doesn't show up in composio.dev, atlascloud, the Zhihu article "The 3 must-install plugins for DeepSeek Harness", Tencent Cloud, or these cnblogs roundups (several of them cover fkysly's list instead); in the local x-radar corpus, bruc3van / awesome-dsh-plugin each appear in 0 entries | None |
| Paid acquisition / star farming | Nothing found. The curve is smooth, with a single-day peak of +9 | Nothing found |
Where the 15,832 IPs come from: the metric is "number of times DSH clients pull the directory (including automatic refreshes)"; the date counting started was never published. Sources could be three: users manually adding it under the Discover tab, dsh-desktop-pro auto-preloading it (since 11-15), and returning users from the earlier safer-dsh-market. The split can't be determined. Also, a claim in the recall rationale needs correcting: saying it was "directly integrated by DSH officially as a third-party index source" is inaccurate. Officially, DSH only offers an "add index source" feature; this source requires users to paste the address themselves. Only the author's own client includes it by default.
4. Competitors
| Competitors | Form | Launched | Scale | How it differs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| awesome-dsh-plugin/awesome-dsh-plugin(fkysly) | open source + website awesome-dsh-plugin.com | 2026-08-13 13:55 | 25,012 stars, 8,852 forks, +7 over the last 810 days | De facto standard directory: plugin authors get listed by submitting a single YAML file, with no install verification; the author has 15.7k followers on X; the companion dsh-market is bundled by several leading desktop clients. This repo is stricter about inclusion and keeps an audit trail, but distribution and reach are two orders of magnitude apart |
| dsh-market/dsh-market + dshmarket.com index | marketplace plugin + index source | 2026-08-14 | 12,761 stars; npm dshmarket 30M downloads in the last 1.28 days | Bundled in clients such as anywhere-labs; the corresponding dsh-market-pro for this repo has only 9 stars |
| AdamPlatin123/awesome-dsh-plugins / dsh-plugin-radar | Open source | 2026-08 | 08-19 at 1,238 stars; radar currently 1,507 | Actually installing each plugin in a container and marking whether it runs is a harder check than this repo's "verify by reading the README". This repo 08-14 even blacklisted it as a "competing directory site" |
| 0xsline/awesome-deepseek-harness | Open source | 2026-08-11 | 1,381 star | A full ecosystem list (plugins + tools + infrastructure), not a subscription source |
| Zhiyuan-Fan / Dominic789654 / libukai / beancookie and other awesome variants | Open source | 2026-08-13/14 | 570 / 434 / 380 / 194 star | Same-named, same-type lists; most have stopped growing |
| imsai-sh/awesome-deepseek-harness-plugins, dshplugin/dsh-plugin-hub, hikariming/dshfind | Open source + website | 2026-08-13~20 | 401 / 539 / 400 star | SEO-focused entry count (claimed 10k–20k entries), with no manual verification |
| Subscription-source peers: dsh.so (9,726 entries, with install verification and security audits), realoiyo (7,490), dsh.works (5,876), polang233, easonmws health index, vlln, and others | index source | From ¥2026-10 | The Zhihu article lists about 14 | A side-by-side option in the same Discover-page dropdown; entry count is mid-sized, and the selling point is "only real plugins, with a star threshold" |
DSH's official Discover page + the plugin_market tool | Big-company features | dsh 0.2.1 (October) | Shipped with official distribution | The official side provides only the mechanism, not a curated directory. That gap is exactly why third-party subscription sources can exist, and it is also the biggest risk (they vanish the day the official side ships its own curation) |
5. Why it earned these 525 stars
- It caught the dsh open-source launch right away: it went live about 1.5 hours after the official repo was created, and got 6 stars in the first 242 days, nearly half the total. That's a platform-event tailwind, not something it built on its own.
- A submission flywheel from plugin authors (small scale): 106 PRs in August, a dedicated self-nomination entry, and 78 external accounts submitting PRs. Authors who want to be listed will naturally go star it.
- Cross-promotion across the author's own product matrix: the directory feeds the client, the client subscribes to the directory by default, and the marketplace plugin reads the directory's data package, keeping traffic within one chain.
- Long-term, high-frequency maintenance: 3 months with 745 commits, audit records published every day, keeping it "alive" among a pile of abandoned same-named lists, sustaining a steady long tail of single-digit daily gains.
Why it didn't reach 25k like fkysly did: (1) the author has no influence on X (posts with a little over a hundred views), while fkysly has 15.7k followers and was reposted by Baoyu the same day; (2) fkysly has its own domain, and its companion marketplace plugin is bundled by a desktop client with 35k stars, while this repo's client has only 98 stars; (3) the inclusion bar is high (verification required), which ends up keeping out the thousands of authors that "submit a YAML and get listed" pulls in; (4) the name collides with the winner, so searching "awesome-dsh-plugin" surfaces the other one first.
6. Differentiation
Compared with 30 other directories and a dozen-plus subscription sources, it differs in four ways:
- Anti-tag-stuffing: adding the
dsh-plugintag doesn't get you listed automatically; the README must actually contain a DSH install path. Every removed entry comes with a stated reason, publicly viewable. - Anti-star-farming: Star alerts plus enhanced analysis (concentrated forks, single contributors, commit cadence, etc.) keep suspicious projects "in the directory but out of the rankings and the marketplace." For example, 11-18 excluded polymarket-proxy from the rankings.
- Recommendations organized by use case, with screenshots: written from "what I want DSH to do" rather than stacking lists by star count.
- Subscribable formats: directory, npm data package, and subscription feed are all provided, so it can go straight into the official Discover page.
These differences are not why it got its stars: the stars mainly came from the first week after open source and from author PRs. The differentiation matters beyond stars: it gives this directory a sellable pitch in the new "subscription source" entry point (real plugins, security, no star farming), matching the 15.8k IPs the site self-reports. That number, however, includes what the author's own client preloads, so how many users the differentiation alone brought in can't be said.
7. Visibility
Almost no one knows about it. It doesn't appear in mainstream roundup articles, English-language media, or the local X corpus; the author's posts have a hundred-plus views; it got one line in a Zhihu subscription-source roundup (6 upvotes), plus auto-indexing by aggregator sites. It's free, so there's no revenue.
8. Copycats
- Direct forks with renamed titles:
Stijnus/awesome-dsh-plugin-bruce(10-24,1 stars),0imzero/awesome-dsh-plugin-bruc3van(10-31,0 stars). - The broader context: the ecosystem was already crowded with same-named directories and subscription sources: 29 awesome-dsh-plugin variants and about 14 subscription sources, none of which were specifically copying it.
9. Takeaways
- As the new Agent ecosystem opened up plugins, it immediately took the "directory" slot, and shipped three formats at once: a README for humans, JSON / npm data packages for programs, and index sources the host can subscribe to directly. When the host later added a subscription mechanism, it could enter the host's Discover page right away.
- Making review a public, auditable process (daily review records, blacklist reasons, star-farming alerts) works as a trust pitch in a sea of "accept everything" directories. Batch review with agents lets one person maintain tens of thousands of entries.
- Directory → own client / marketplace plugin → default subscribed directory is a closed loop. But you need a sufficiently large distribution endpoint first, or the loop just circulates your own small traffic.
- The negative lesson: name and first-mover advantage aren't enough. The winner relied on author influence + a low inclusion bar to pull in suppliers + being bundled by leading clients, and this repo lacks all three.
10. Uncertain
- It's unknown from what date the 15,832 IPs and 47,459 pulls were counted, or how many came from dsh-desktop-pro's automatic preloading.
- The GitHub stargazers endpoint returned 404, so the timestamp of each star can't be retrieved, and the August distribution for the first few days can't be broken down.
- The creation date of dsh-desktop-pro's repo is 08-12, earlier than dsh's open-sourcing; it may have been renamed from another older repo. Not verified.
- The author's X follower count wasn't obtained; only view counts on individual posts were visible.
Sources
- GitHub API: repos/bruc3van/awesome-dsh-plugin-pro (metadata, commits, pulls, contributors, contents: README, data/stats.json, data/review/2026-11-18.md, 2026-11-17-market-pro-rename.md); repos/awesome-dsh-plugin/awesome-dsh-plugin; repos/bruc3van/dsh-desktop-pro (releases, CHANGELOG, src/main/preset-subscription.ts); repos/bruc3van/dsh-market-pro
- deepseek-ai/deepseek-harness Discussion #3395 "Weekly observations on the community plugin market" (08-19)
- Site bruc3van.com/dsh-plugins/ (11-18 crawl, counter) and bruc3van.com/projects/awesome-dsh-plugin-pro/
- Trendshift trendshift.io/repositories/146163 (09-19 to 11-18 daily star gains)
- X: x.com/bruc3van/status/2120464621224243371 (11-11,115 views), x.com/bruc3van/status/2111499486023598330 (10-17)
- Zhihu zhuanlan.zhihu.com/p/2097287594757440531 (subscription-source roundup, 10-25 editor)
- npm:registry.npmjs.org and api.npmjs.org (awesome-dsh-plugin-feed, safer-dsh-market, dsh-market-pro, dshmarket)
- GitHub code search: ALL-PAY-C/HarnessForAndroid PluginMarket.kt; brickhu/dsh-plugins commercial/research/platform.md
- Our GitHub repo_profile / repo_day (11-18); x-radar local corpus (0 items)
- Existing report in the same ecosystem: /home/ljr/fanout/why/out/gh_dsh-market__dsh-market.md