
"One leaf looks off, so fix that leaf": klad, the drawing tool that lets coding agents pick up a brush, 15 days 309 stars
What it is A desktop painting and animation app. Coding agents like Claude Code and Codex can paint on it stroke by stroke from the command line, and a person can edit any stroke the agent made, and the reverse works too.
Why it took off Claude Fable 5.2 had just launched and everyone was watching AI paint strokes. Adobe had just announced that agent edits to Photoshop wouldn't reach internal beta until next year. The author posted a Show HN right then, with the one-liner "image generation is a gacha; here every stroke can be edited" and a demo GIF, and it reached the front page. The next day he shipped a pixel-art version and posted on Reddit, which added another wave.
BHow you could follow it Don't build another painting app. Pick tools that are still manual, like audio, level editors, motion graphics or CAD, and build versions where every step is editable and agents can drive them from the command line. Release under MIT, make it installable or playable in the browser, and post a Show HN in the week a new model drops.
- Data (updated daily) · Repo created 2026-11-04 · 318 stars · 7 days +156
GitHub · stars Data 2026-11-12 → 2026-11-20 (9 days, 9 observations). Points before 10-28 come from deeply / archive backfill, not every day has one
klad is a 2D painting and animation app written in Rust. You draw with a pen tablet in the editor, while coding agents like Claude Code and Codex paint on the same canvas through the klad CLI. Every stroke either side makes can be edited again. It was created 11-04 and had 309 stars by 11-19. Its size comes mostly from timing: new models had just learned to paint stroke by stroke, and Adobe had just announced agent editing of Photoshop files that wouldn't ship for 2027 years, so the Show HN landed in that gap. If you want an open-source project that can earn stars the same way, klad's approach of making a creative tool something an agent can operate directly is worth studying. Building yet another painting app is not.
A Show HN from the afternoon of Nov 11
On 2026 Nov 11 16:00 (UTC), an old Hacker News account that had been around since 2015 posted: "Show HN: Klad, a paint app your coding agent can drive." Before this, ambewas had shared small tools on HN like a guitar scale app and a chord player. The post opened with a problem that had been bugging them:
I've started making games recently, and the most annoying part of using AI agents for game art is the art. There are only two options: use an image model, where every change means rolling the dice again, or have the agent assemble vectors. I wanted the agent to first sketch with a real brush, and then I could go in and change every stroke and layer it painted.
In the post he pointed to two events from that week: "I've been using it since Fable 5.2 came out on Monday, and the drawings already look pretty decent," and "Adobe demoed agent edits to Photoshop files at MAX this week, with internal beta not until early 2027, while klad works today." The only instruction for trying it was one line: hand the repo to Claude, let it build itself, and let it learn the drawing skill.
Over an hour later the post reached #12 on the HN front page, stayed there for 22 hours, and finished with 85 points and 34 comments. The author replied to nearly every one. Someone asked how it differed from having an agent write SVG directly. He answered that each stroke is stored as data like a vector, but when it lands it behaves like paint: it can smudge and blend, which SVG can't do. One user had Opus 5.5 draw some characters and said they looked "less obviously AI than the usual stuff." Others tested it carefully and were less impressed: image generation followed by video conversion still looked more natural. The author admitted the bottleneck is the model, saying it "feels like coding two years ago."
What it is
- The painter and the agent share one canvas. You paint in the editor while the agent runs
kladcommands in the terminal, and each side sees the other's strokes in real time. You can pin a sticky note to the canvas or box off a region with "add more moss here," and the agent can read it. - Every stroke is data, not pixels. Path, pressure, brush and color are all stored, and only at render time do they become paint effects. Even smudging is a stroke you can move. So hours later you can still pick out one stroke the agent painted and change its color, bend it, move it or delete it. The README puts it this way: "There is no re-rolling the dice. If a leaf looks wrong, fix that leaf."
- The feature set is a full painting app. Twenty-plus brushes, layers, masks, vector and text tools, a timeline, onion skinning, auto-tweening, and bone IK. 11-12 added pixel art (it can import and export Aseprite files), and 11-17 added map layers. It exports PNG, sprite sheets, and GIF, and it can import straight into Godot.
- The file is plain text in a folder, so it goes into git and diffs read cleanly. There's no AI model in the software itself; what it looks like depends on the agent you use.
- Ships with three instruction files for agents:
klad skill(how to operate it),klad skill drawing(how to think about composition, lighting, and color), andklad skill pixel(pixel art and animation). All MIT.
The GIF at the top of the README is its best ad: an agent draws a little sprout monster stroke by stroke, a human changes the leaf color and bends the mouth into a smile, then the agent splits it into parts, sets keyframes, and makes it walk. The night scene and twelve game props next to it are labeled "drawn by Claude Fable 5.2." When it was relayed on Chinese X, the number that got picked up was "4344 strokes."
It is not open source. The source is public, and individuals and companies with under 500k EUR in prior-year revenue can compile it for free; bigger companies pay $49 per seat. The file format, command reference, and the three instruction files are MIT. The author plans to sell compiled installers, like Aseprite does. The site is collecting emails: pre-order at $15, then $19 at launch, one-time purchase. The installers are still waiting on Apple signing, and the author says an MCP server will follow once they ship.
Who built it: the GitHub org klad-app and the commit account quantumwhisker were both registered on 11-04. An AI tool review site names the developer as Indicode BV, a small Belgian company (only one source, not verified). "Klad" means "draft" in Dutch.
Where the stars came from: one HN post, one Reddit post, then a slow flatten
| Date | star | Gained that day | What happened those days |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11-11 | — | — | Show HN posted on 16:00, reached the front page for 22 hours |
| 11-12 | 86 | — | HN traffic; several AI news accounts on Chinese X relayed it, peaking around 1,100 views |
| 11-13 | 162 | +76 | On 11-12 afternoon, v0.2.0 shipped pixel art, delivering on the HN promise of "pixel art this weekend." The same day it went to r/vibecoding ("I built Klad with Claude… now with pixel art") and r/aigamedev ("klad: give your coding agent real brushes"). |
| 11-14 | 180 | +18 | The author opened the @klad_studio X account; posts there got almost no views. |
| 11-15 | 230 | +50 | AI tool repost accounts on Instagram, YouTube Shorts, and Facebook posted short videos captioned "comment KLAD and I'll DM you the build steps." |
| 11-16 | 269 | +39 | Same thing: forks went from 11 to 17. |
| 11-17 | 287 | +18 | v0.3.0 |
| 11-19 | 309 | +6 | Decline |
Sources: GitHub daily star snapshots; HN post 50454951; Reddit post titles from search results, scores and comment counts unavailable.
Breaking it down:
- Show HN was the first push. The title says what it is in one line, the body rode two trending topics from that week, and the author stayed in the comments all day and invited people to submit their work to the "Made with klad" gallery.
- The next day, they shipped a feature and used it as a new reason to post again. When the pixel art version came out, they took it to two subreddits. The single-day high of +76 came that day.
- The repost accounts came to it on their own. The short-video accounts with "comment KLAD and I'll DM you" and a batch of AI news sites followed within 0 to 2 days of the HN post. The copy style looks like their own choice of topic, not something the author paid for (inferred).
- X barely moved the needle. No big accounts reshared it. The top post was an AI weekly newsletter account's "YOUR AGENT GOT A PAINTBRUSH THIS WEEK" with 42 likes.
No sign of star farming: the curve lines up with HN, Reddit, and release timing, and forks are about 6% of stars, which means people really are cloning and building it.
Why this week
Models had just learned to paint. Claude Fable 5.2 was released that week. Anthropic staff posted on X about Claude painting stroke by stroke with simulated brushes, and r/ClaudeAI and r/aigamedev filled with test posts of Fable making pixel art. People were curious whether LLMs could paint at all, and klad gave them something to try hands-on.
Big companies had announced, but not shipped. The same week, Adobe MAX announced that Photoshop, Illustrator, and others would get local MCP access so external agents could edit files, with an internal beta starting in early 2027. klad's line "it works today" caught that curiosity.
One line hit the pain point. "Image generation is a slot machine; if one leaf is crooked, you start over." Anyone who has used image generators for assets has hit this. HN comments and every repost account repeated it.
The build barrier was handed off to the agent. Compiling a Rust painting app by hand takes ten-plus minutes and can go wrong; "give Claude the repo and let it build it" hands that step to the agent. The README even includes a ready-made prompt.
Who else is doing the same thing
| Project | Scale | How klad differs |
|---|---|---|
| Adobe Photoshop / Illustrator agent interface | All Adobe users | Edits the pro software's own files; internal beta started in early 2027 |
| patch-gg/pixelfx | 20 days, 8,121 stars, last 7 days +1,169 | 244 pixel effects, each a bit of code, MIT, viewable right on the web page; not a painting tool, but grew much faster in the same period |
| 0x0funky/agent-sprite-forge | 5,826 star | Has an agent generate sprite sheets and animations; the output is finished files, not something you can keep editing stroke by stroke |
| with-pebbly/aseprite-ai-artist | 72 stars in 702 days | Plugs into Aseprite while it's already open; pixel art only |
| ahujasid/mcp-for-blender | 34,932 star | The same idea as 3D, letting agents operate existing software |
| gimp-mcp and Photoshop control bridges | From a few dozen to over three thousand stars | Adds an interface to existing software, but edits pixels, not strokes |
| Image generators (Scenario, PixelLab, Retro Diffusion, etc.) | Commercial products at scale. | Output is pixels; changing one spot means re-rolling the whole image |
Sources: GitHub repo pages and daily snapshots, 11-19.
The combination of "a built-in painting engine, editable strokes, and humans and agents sharing one canvas" is, among open source projects, currently only klad, and nobody has copied it yet (the 19 forks are ordinary forks, and no comparable new project has appeared in nearly 30 days). But in the same broad area, none of the projects that reached thousands or tens of thousands of stars are this one.
Where it gets stuck: why it's only at three hundred
The differentiation is the reason people click through, but it also sets several hurdles: you have to compile it yourself; pen pressure is fully supported only on Mac, Linux needs tweaking, and the author hasn't used it on Windows; the license isn't open source, and some developers won't star something labeled "source-available." There is no web version; the author says thousands of editable strokes won't run in a browser.
The comparison is clear: pixelfx, an MIT project you can play with right in a web page, gained 20 stars in 8,000 days in the same period; mcp-for-blender, which connects an agent to Blender, has 35k. klad's work is more hardcore but spreads more narrowly, mostly among indie game developers who use agents for art. After the HN wave passed, it's down to single digits a day.
If it were you
One takeaway: don't build another agent painting app. What's worth learning is the recipe: find a creative tool that still needs a human at the controls, make it something an agent can operate directly, and launch in the few days after a new model drops and a big company announces but hasn't shipped.
Who it suits: developers who know one kind of creative tool (audio editing, music production, level editors, motion graphics, CAD, fonts, maps), can build an agent-driven core feature themselves, and are willing to stay in the comments on launch day.
Who it doesn't suit: anyone who wants to head-to-head klad on 2D painting. A Rust brush engine is a huge engineering effort, klad already holds that spot, and Adobe is coming; even if you finish it, you'll likely end up with a few hundred stars. If you just want stars and don't want to build something hard, a small MIT library like pixelfx is the better bet.
How to do it:
- Pick a domain and make "every step is editable data" the core: store operations as data instead of only results, keep files as plain text that works with git, and let the agent read back and see what it did.
- Give every feature a command, support submitting batches of operations as JSON, and ship instruction files for agents under MIT so others can reuse them.
- Leave a way for humans to feed intent back in, like klad's sticky notes and selection boxes.
- Lower the barrier, the spot where klad fell short: MIT open source, a web version or an installer you can run directly, so within a minute of opening it people can see the agent working.
How to get users: post Show HN with a title that says in one line "what your coding agent can do with it," and name that week's new model and big-company moves in the body. Put a looping GIF at the top of the README: the agent does a pass, a human changes one thing, the agent continues, with a note on which model did the work. The day after, ship a feature you promised in the post and post it again to the relevant subreddit. Set up a gallery on the site to collect user work.
When to move: Adobe's agent interface started its internal beta in early 2027, and other big-company software will probably follow with agent interfaces of their own (inferred). Once they all have them, "creative tools agents can operate" stops being new, so the window is roughly the next six months. The week any new model launches is the best time to release.
What would show this read is wrong: if klad's stars re-accelerate after the installers and MCP server ship, that means the barrier was its ceiling and painting still has room. If similar projects in audio, 3D sculpting, and other areas launch and stall at a few dozen stars, then klad mostly rode the heat of the Fable 5.2 week, and the recipe stops working without the timing.
Research notes: competitor table, acquisition evidence, full research report
- Competitors
Name Where Launched Scale How it differs from this one Adobe Photoshop/Illustrator local MCP + Creative Agent Big-company features Announced at Adobe MAX 2026-11, internal beta in early 2027 All Adobe users Edits the pro software's native files, not yet open to the public; klad works today, and every stroke is still editable data with-pebbly/aseprite-ai-artist Open source About 2026-09 702 stars (72 days) The MCP bridge runs on Aseprite while it's already open and handles pixel art only; klad has its own painting engine with oil paint, vector, and bone animation patch-gg/pixelfx Open source About 2026-10-30 8121 stars (20 days, +1169 in the last 7 days) An MIT pixel-effects library plus a Claude Code skill; viewable right on the web page, low barrier; not a painting editor 0x0funky/agent-sprite-forge Open source About 2026-04 5826 star Has agents generate sprite sheets and animations in one pass; the output is a result file, and you can't keep editing it stroke by stroke skulitom/Pixelbolt / Gamezxz/pixel-art-studio Open source 2026-07~09 123 / 121 star JSON recipes or pixel-by-pixel CLI/skills for generating art; no editor built for people to use ahujasid/mcp-for-blender, arjun988/blender-skills Open source 2025 / 2026-07 34932 / 4251 star In the 3D space, agents operating ready-made software; klad is 2D and builds its own engine gimp-mcp / photoshop-beta-control / harness-anything and other MCP bridges Open source 2025–2026 74–3176 star They edit pixels or the host app's objects, not stroke data excalidraw-diagram-skill / mcp_excalidraw / tldraw Open source 2025–2026 5290 / 2667 / 51477 star Vector whiteboards and charts, not painting The ArtCraft family (procraft etc.) Open source 2026-10 procraft 885 stars (27 days) AI-written Adobe alternatives; open-source painting apps, not built for agents Image-generation models (Scenario, PixelLab, Retro Diffusion, etc.) Other Years Big The output is pixels, so one fix means rerolling; klad's pitch is the opposite - Where users come from
- Verified Show HN: posted 11-11 16:00 UTC, 85 points, 34 comments, front page for 22 hours, peaking at #12; the post name-checks Fable 5.2 and Adobe MAX; the author replied to nearly every comment
- Verified Reddit organic posts: r/vibecoding "I built Klad with Claude… now with pixel art" and r/aigamedev "klad: give your coding agent real brushes", same period as v0.2.0, matching a single-day +11-13 on 76; scores not retrieved
- Verified Platform event / new model release: Claude Fable 5.2 released around 11-09; Anthropic staff posted brushstroke paintings made by Fable on X (the-decoder 11-15); the same week Adobe MAX announced agents editing Photoshop files
- Verified Third-party repost accounts / auto-news sites: Instagram "Comment KLAD" reels, YouTube Antonio Monteiro short videos, Facebook videos; stackfutures, hamidun, aitodaybrief, promptzone, hokai, daily.dev published write-ups 0–2 days after HN
- Verified X: no big accounts; @Alexvx_nft's weekly roundup got 42 likes, Chinese account @tvytlx about 1089 views; the official @klad_studio opened 11-14 and gets almost 0 views
- Verified Site social proof + user gallery: klad.studio shows the star count, the HN link, and two HN user quotes, and collects user work (two pieces are credited to quantumWhisker, the same as the submitting account)
klad-app/klad: why it works
Data as of 2026-11-19 (data card refresh date). Star counts come from our github library repo_day, HN data from the hackernews library, X data from x live (live query to the official X API).
Bottom line
Rust-based 2D painting and animation desktop app. Brushes, layers, and timeline are all exposed as klad commands, so Claude Code, Codex, and other coding agents can paint alongside a human on the same canvas, stroke by stroke. Every stroke is stored as editable data, not pixels. It hit Show HN in the same week as the Claude Fable 5.2 launch (11-09 that week, Anthropic staff posting on X about a painting Claude drew stroke by stroke) and Adobe MAX announcing external agents editing Photoshop files, with an internal beta at the start of 2027. It stayed on the HN front page for 22 hours, peaking at #12. Over the next two days it shipped pixel art v0.2.0, then got reshared by r/aigamedev, r/vibecoding, Chinese X accounts, and a batch of AI tool repost accounts with 'comment KLAD and I'll DM you' hooks. 15 days, 309 stars. The stars came mostly from timing plus one good demo GIF. The differentiator ('no gacha, every stroke stays editable') is the line that gets people to click, but the reach is modest and already fading (11-19 single-day gain: +6).
What it is
- Repo: github.com/klad-app/klad, created 2026-11-04. The klad-app org and submitting account quantumwhisker were both registered 11-04 the same day; the HN poster is ambewas (an old account registered 2015 years ago, which previously posted Show HN for a guitar scale tool and a chord player). The evaluation site hokai.io lists the developer as Indicode BV, a small company in Wijnegem, Belgium (companyweb.be BE0727599275). In Dutch, klad means "draft."
- Features: 23 brushes (oil paint with texture, smudging as a movable stroke), vectors and text, layers, masks, timeline, onion skin, auto-tweening, bone IK, a pixel layer (imports and exports Aseprite files), and export to PNG / sprite sheets / GIF / Godot SpriteFrames and TileSet. You can pin sticky notes and select regions on the canvas, which the agent can read. The file format is a folder of plain-text files that can go straight into git. Documented in the repo README and on the site.
- Licensing and pricing: source-available, not open source. Individuals and companies with prior-year revenue under €500k can compile it themselves for free; larger companies pay $49 per seat. The file format, CLI reference, and three agent skills are MIT. Prebuilt installers aren't out yet, and the site is taking emails: list price $15, launch price $19, one-time purchase including all 1.x updates (klad.studio/pricing). In the HN post the author's own words were "sell prebuilt packages the way Aseprite does."
- Versions: v0.1.17 (11-12), v0.2.0 pixel art (11-12), v0.3.0 tilemap layers (11-17). Commits clustered between 11-10 and 11-12, 75 times in three days (GitHub API).
Growth curve and channels (by time)
| Date (snapshot) | star | Added that day | Events in the same period |
|---|---|---|---|
| 11-04 | — | — | Repo created |
| About 11-09/10 | — | — | Claude Fable 5.2 released (anthropic.com/claude-fable-and-mythos-5-2); Anthropic staff Jake Eaton and Michael Graczyk posted on X Fable paintings made stroke by stroke with simulated brushes (the-decoder 11-15 coverage); the same week Adobe MAX announced local MCP for Photoshop / Illustrator / Premiere / AE, with an early beta 2027 (news.adobe.com, gadgetsnow) |
| 11-11 16:00 UTC | — | — | Show HN posted. 17:17 reached #12 on the front page, stayed in the top 90 for 22 hours, finishing at 84–85 points and 34 comments (hackernews library story 50454951) |
| 11-12 | 86 | — | First record in the library, already picking up HN traffic; Chinese X accounts @tvytlx (1089 views), @xqliu, @JakerJoe1 relayed it |
| 11-13 | 162 | +76 (single-day peak) | v0.2.0 pixel art 11-12 15:05 released; r/vibecoding "I built Klad with Claude… now with pixel art"; r/aigamedev "klad: give your coding agent real brushes"; @Alexvx_nft's weekly roundup "YOUR AGENT GOT A PAINTBRUSH THIS WEEK" (42 likes, 1656 views) |
| 11-14 | 180 | +18 | The author opened the @klad_studio X account; posts there mostly get 0–5 views |
| 11-15 | 230 | +50 | AI tool repost accounts on Instagram / YouTube Shorts / Facebook posted videos ("Comment KLAD and I'll send you the build steps"), and the-decoder published an article on Fable's paintings |
| 11-16 | 269 | +39 | Same thing: forks went from 11 to 17. |
| 11-17 | 287 | +18 | v0.3.0 |
| 11-18 | 303 | +16 | |
| 11-19 | 309 | +6 | Decline |
Sources: github library repo_day; HN observations; x live search for "klad" (29 posts in the last 7 days, top 42 likes); Reddit post titles from Jina / Exa search results (Reddit refused scraping, scores and comment counts not retrieved).
Channel breakdown
- Show HN: the title just says "a paint app your coding agent can drive". The post rides two trends at once: "I've been using it since Fable 5.2 dropped on Monday" and "Adobe demoed an agent editing Photoshop files at MAX this week, and it's invite-only until 2027 early next year. klad works today." The author replied to nearly every comment and invited people to submit their work to the "Made with klad" gallery.
- Self-posted to Reddit (confirmed, titles found): the r/vibecoding post opens with "I built Klad with Claude," riding the vibecoding narrative; r/aigamedev targets people making games with AI. In the same window r/aigamedev, r/ClaudeAI, and r/ClaudeCode were full of "Fable 5.2 makes pixel art" posts (benchmarks, blind tests), and klad landed right in that discussion.
- Third-party repost accounts and auto-news sites (confirmed, not made by the author): Instagram DM-funnel reels ("comment KLAD / comment TOOL"), YouTube Antonio Monteiro ("More Leads & Sales With AI") short videos, and videos on one Facebook page; AI news sites stackfutures, hamidun, aitodaybrief (Ukrainian), promptzone, hokai, daily.dev, and zerodaily auto-generated articles 0–2 days after HN. They pick topics off HN.
- X (weak): no big accounts reposted it. The highest was the weekly roundup account @Alexvx_nft (42 likes), followed by a few Chinese AI news accounts (around 1000 views). The official @klad_studio opened only 11-14 and almost nobody saw it.
- Social proof on the site: the klad.studio homepage shows "310 stars on GitHub" and "Discussed on Hacker News," quotes two HN users' hands-on tests, and features user work in the gallery. Two gallery pieces are credited to quantumWhisker, the same as the submitting account, so the author probably made them.
- No sign of paid ads or star-buying: the curve lines up with HN, Reddit, and version-release timing, the forks come from normal-looking accounts, and fork/star is about 6%. The stargazer list endpoint returned 404 this time, so the accounts couldn't be checked one by one.
Competitors: who else does the same thing
There are four routes for "letting coding agents paint / make game art" right now.
| Competitors | Form | Launched | Scale | How klad differs |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adobe Photoshop / Illustrator local MCP + Creative Agent | Big-company features | Announced at Adobe MAX 2026-11, internal beta in early 2027 | All Adobe users | Edits the pro software's native files, not yet open; klad works today, and every stroke stays an editable stroke |
| with-pebbly/aseprite-ai-artist | Open source (MCP + skill) | About 2026-09 | 702 stars (72 days) | Bridges into Aseprite the user already has open, pixel art only; klad is its own painting engine and handles oil paint, vectors, and skeletal animation |
| patch-gg/pixelfx | Open source (effects library + Claude Code skill) | About 2026-10-30 | 8121 stars (20 days), +7 in the last 1169 days | 244 pixel effects, each a piece of code, MIT, viewable on the web; low barrier and fast spread, but not a painting tool |
| 0x0funky/agent-sprite-forge | Open source (skill) | About 2026-04 | 5826 star | Lets agents generate sprites and animations; the output is a result file, you can't keep editing it stroke by stroke |
| skulitom/Pixelbolt, Gamezxz/pixel-art-studio | Open source (CLI / MCP / skill) | 2026-07~09 | 123 / 121 star | Uses JSON recipes or per-pixel generation, no editor for humans |
| ahujasid/mcp-for-blender, arjun988/blender-skills | Open source (MCP / skill, 3D) | 2025 / 2026-07 | 34932 / 4251 star | The same idea as in 3D: agents drive existing software. It shows that "agent-driven creative tools" can pull large star counts. |
| gimp-mcp, kiki348/photoshop-beta-control, dcc-mcp-core, harness-anything | Open source (MCP bridges) | 2025–2026 | 74–3176 star | Adds MCP to existing software; it edits pixels or host-app objects, not stroke data |
| coleam00/excalidraw-diagram-skill, mcp_excalidraw, tldraw | Open source (whiteboards / diagrams) | 2025–2026 | 5290 / 2667 / 51477 star | Vector diagrams and whiteboards, not painting |
| The ArtCraft family (artcraft-android/procraft, etc.) | Open source (AI-written Adobe alternative) | 2026-10 | procraft 885 stars (27 days) | An open-source painting app, not built for agents. On HN someone asked "Isn't ArtCraft already agent-ready?" The author replied that klad's file format is designed for editable strokes and git |
| "Just have the model write SVG or simulate brushes in Python" | No product; the model itself | Popular after Fable 5.2 launched | Work by Anthropic staff spread widely on X | One-off scripts that can't be revised after painting. klad turns that process into a file you can save, hand off, and edit |
| Image-generation models (Scenario, PixelLab, Retro Diffusion, etc.) | Commercial SaaS | Years | Big | The output is pixels, so one fix means rerolling; klad's pitch is the opposite |
Verdict: there are many similar tools, but the combination of "a full painting engine built in, editable strokes, and humans and agents sharing one canvas" is, for now, unique to klad in open source. The closest are aseprite-ai-artist (pixel art only, depends on Aseprite) and Adobe (not yet shipped).
Why it took off
- Timing: Fable 5.2 launched, and "LLM draws pixel art stroke by stroke" became the hot topic on X and Reddit that same week (a the-decoder 11-15 article, plus a stream of Fable pixel art posts on r/ClaudeAI and r/aigamedev). Adobe MAX announced agents editing Photoshop files the same week. klad 11-11 posted on HN and name-dropped both in the body.
- A one-line pain point: "Image models are slot machines; if one leaf is crooked, you just rerun." Several HN commenters said "finally, usable results" and "easier to control than in-painting"; aggregator accounts repeated the line verbatim.
- Strong demo assets: the GIF at the top of the README shows an agent drawing a sprout monster (4344 strokes), a human changing the leaf color, bending the mouth, and smudging a patch, then the agent makes it walk. The scene art, prop pack, and knight pixel animation are all labeled "drawn by Claude Fable 5.2." The Chinese repost picked up the "4344 strokes" number.
- Fast follow-up: the day after HN, the promised pixel-art v0.2.0 shipped, and a Reddit post used it as the hook for a single-day peak of +76. v0.3.0 followed, plus a user gallery.
- Distribution designed for agents: the
klad skillhands the instructions straight to the agent; the README includes a ready-made prompt; the HN post says "give the repo to Claude and let it compile it." The ten-minute compile hurdle is handled by the agent.
Differentiation, and whether it's a manufactured ranking
The difference is architectural: every stroke (path, pressure, brush, color), every fill, and even smudges are stored as data, and only turned into paint effects at render time. So humans can edit what agents draw stroke by stroke and vice versa; files go into git and can be diffed. Rivals either add MCP to existing software (editing pixels or host objects), generate one-off images or code (not revisable), or do image generation (slot machines). The sharing was one source of stars, since it's the selling line in the HN title and every repost. But the timing set the scale. The difference also brings friction: you compile it yourself, pen pressure is only fully supported on Mac, and the license isn't open source. Over the same period, pixelfx, an MIT-licensed tool you can play in the browser, gained 20 times as many stars, while klad had 8000 309. So it's "small and precise": the people spreading it are indie game developers who use agents for art.
How visible it is
It circulated in niche circles: it reached the HN front page (85 points, 22 hours on the front page), two subreddits, a batch of automated news sites, and DM-funneling accounts. There were no big X accounts; the top post had 42 likes. No mainstream tech outlet covered it on its own. Revenue isn't public, only a pre-sale email list and public prices ($15/$19/$49 per person). Copycats: none so far. The 19 forks are ordinary forks, not renamed rebrands, and GitHub search turned up no new "agent painting engine" repos in the last 30 days.
What others can borrow
- A recipe for making an author's tool agent-native: every feature has a CLI, operations are submitted as batched JSON, output can be read back, it ships with a skill doc (MIT, to spread it), the file format is public and lives in git, and the canvas gives humans a sticky note / selection to send intent back. The same approach could move to audio editing, level editors, 3D sculpting (someone on HN already asked), CAD, and motion graphics.
- Business model modeled on Aseprite: source is public and free to compile yourself; sell signed prebuilt binaries, plus per-seat fees above a revenue threshold. Use HN and GitHub heat to collect pre-sale emails first.
- Release rhythm: post Show HN during the window after a new model launches and big labs announce features that haven't shipped; the next day, deliver a promised feature and use it to post on Reddit again.
- Demos should be a continuous GIF of "same character: agent draws, human edits, then it moves," with a note naming the model that drew it.
Still unclear
- The scores, comment counts, and posting times for the two Reddit posts (Reddit blocks scraping), and whether the r/aigamedev Fable pixel-art benchmark post was by the same author.
- The view counts of the Instagram, YouTube, and Facebook repost accounts, and whether the author paid for them (the writing style suggests third-party DM-funneling accounts chose the topic themselves).
- Whether ambewas and quantumwhisker are the same person, and whether Indicode BV is the author's company (only one source, hokai).
- How many people are on the pre-sale list and how many real installs there are: the repo only shows stars and forks.
- The stargazer list endpoint returned 404, so individual star accounts can't be checked one by one.